***Your ideal cast for Batman 3?***

[EliteF50]

We have plenty of "Would ________ play a good _________?" threads, so I thought we might as well make one huge thread.

Anyways, these are my picks for cast members.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bane: Dwayne Johnson

http://i28.tinypic.com/16lbgc5.png

Catwoman: Jessica Alba

http://www.aolcdn.com/red_galleries/jessica-alba-400a0524.jpg

Riddler: Johnny Depp

http://www.nightly.net/z/wp-content/uploads/2008/07/riddler.jpg

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So, who do you think will be in B3? Make sure to list an actor/actress as well!

[Batfan22]

Johnny Depp as riddler would be sick

[Ensanguined Walls]

Riddler: David Tennant

http://img.thesun.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00675/David-Tennant-280_675721a.jpg
http://www.sfsignal.com/mt-static/images/doctorWho-Tennant.JPG
http://celebrity-pics.movieeye.com/celebrity_pictures/David_Tennant_462002.jpg

[EliteF50]

Yeah, he looks like he would make a good Riddler too.

[Jason Todd]

Lol Rock would be a good Bane...he's playing I read somewhere Black Adam in the Shazam/Captain Marvel Movie, and he's a perfect fit, I say Riddler - Depp, Angelina Jolie as Catwoman and Ron Pearlman as Clayface...

[Turn and Face the Strange]

RIDDLER: David Tennant

http://www.recapist.com/files/images/61774_david-tennant-specs.jpg
http://nightshade01.files.wordpress.com/2008/10/david_tennant_09.jpg

SCARECROW: Cillian Murphy

http://screenrant.com/wp-content/uploads/murphy.jpg

[EliteF50]

Black Adam in the Shazam/Captain Marvel Movie

I hope so.

http://www.slashfilm.com/wp/wp-content/images/therockblackadam.jpeg

[Batfan22]

I KNOW! arnold schwarzenegger as Mr.freeze ... what did i say?

[Ensanguined Walls]

David Tennant said that he would love to portray the Riddler, and he's a fantastic actor. He was a terrific Dr. Who, and he's excellent as portraying twisted, delusional characters. He was Bartimus Crouch Jr. in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/media/images/40966000/jpg/_40966980_bartycrouchjnr.jpg
http://www.filmdope.com/Gallery/ActorsT/55963-26575.gif

http://www.exposay.com/celebrity-photos/david-tennant-harry-potter-and-the-order-of-the-phoenix-london-movie-premiere-arrivals-3WIlRK.jpg

[Why So Serious ?]

as bane
http://z.about.com/d/prowrestling/1/0/_/H/-/-/BROCKLESNAR058.jpg
as Riddler
http://www.chattahbox.com/images/Johnny_Depp_Riddler_Batman.jpg
as Joker
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_KTJWhtuRLac/R7YdQwSa26I/AAAAAAAABIE/xBZA1xbRZew/s400/willem_defoe.jpg
as catwomen
http://www.exposay.com/celebrity-photos/olivia-munn-the-break-up-world-premiere-cX82PC.jpg
as Ivy
http://www.insidesocal.com/outinhollywood/kristanna_loken.jpg

[Ensanguined Walls]

Megan Fox may look nice due to excessive make-up and surgery, but she simply can't act.

Listen to her converse. Does her voice sound seductive at all? No: it sounds nasally and obnoxious.

[EliteF50]

Megan Fox may look nice due to excessive make-up and surgery, but she simply can't act.

Listen to her converse. Does her voice sound seductive at all? No: it sounds nasally and obnoxious.

Agreed. Even when she tries to sound sexy in TF2, she just sounds annoying.

[Jason Todd]

I think Lesnar should've played Eddie Brock to be honest, same build and everything. Would've made more sense than Topher Grace...and yeah, Black Adam's one of my Favorites so I'd see it just because I know Rock would be great in that role

[The Hylden]

... Alba?? Eesh, haven't seen anything she's acted well in. As far as decent actresses, Jolie, or Johansen, maybe... I don't know. Not many are coming to mind as this moment, which is a shame...

I like the other choices. I'll have to think on this a bit for characters and actors that can play them...

What I'd love, despite rumors to the contrary even by Nolan, is that Dent is still alive, kept hidden in Arkham, and the whole continuation of Batman on the run, all of that wonderful story set-up, played out as only Nolan has shown he can do. I don't really want to see a new love interest for Bruce, but maybe a helpful strong female lead (unless it's Selina, of course). It would be interesting if, in the process of her cat-burgling, she sees Batman and has to help him escape the hard arm of the law after him, kind of like how I read it in Year One recently. Although, if they make Sleina Kyle into a dom lesbian, I will have to veto the movie:p Nothing against lesbians, but that wasn't Selina Kyle... Anyway... In this one arc throughout the film, the heavy weight on Batman woul be that a criminal has helped him, one he's falling for, but his moral code eats at him. Meanwhile, Two face getting out of Arkham, maybe helped by Bane, or found by Bane, or some other entity (maybe Penguin -- as a mafia boss that's taken over after Joker's rampage, or if they want to replace Joker and continue it that way), and now you have a monster that Batman has kind of let be created reeking havoc on Gotham with his new ally (s), a Cat-burglar that he's falling in love with -- talk about eating away at the code he's trying to live by. Oh, and the cops still after him, with lethal force, for the wrong reasons. I don't know. Maybe it's too many characters. It's so hard to speculate, really. I am sure, if Nolan does it, though, he'll do it right.

Edit: I honestly have to say, David Tennant there looks PERFECT as The Riddler. Depp has come real competition there :) Uh, sorry Why So Serious?, Megan Fox is a far worse actress than Alba! Please, taker her away... lol And I don't get why people think she's all that hot. She isn't...

[EliteF50]

If anyone here sees Dwayne at Comic Con this year, please ask him to talk about playing Bane with Chris Nolan!

I think Lesnar should've played Eddie Brock to be honest, same build and everything. Would've made more sense than Topher Grace...and yeah, Black Adam's one of my Favorites so I'd see it just because I know Rock would be great in that role

Yeah, Lesnar would play a good Venom. Bane... not so much.

As for Black Adam, the movie was cancelled early this year. :(

[Why So Serious ?]

ok i changed catwoman and added one

[Gallagher]

I'm on the Depp bandwagon, he's easily my favorite actor and I think he would make an amazing Riddler.

Philip Seymour Hoffman could definitely pull off Penguin.

[batfan08]

Thomas Elliot/Hush-Brad Pitt

Harvey Dent/Two-Face-Aaron Eckhart

Harvey Bullock-James Gandolfini

Maybe:
Renee Montoya-Mariska Hargitay

[DropkickDisco]

Catwoman: Cher

http://img.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2006/06/cherG_297x450.jpg

[EliteF50]

0_0 Really?

[batfan08]

ALL-STAR Cast for Batman R.I.P
Catwoman: Cher

http://img.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2006/06/cherG_297x450.jpg

Batman:Sonny

[DropkickDisco]

0_0 Really?

Yes, I actually like the idea

[Why So Serious ?]

ALL-STAR Cast for Batman R.I.P


Batman:Sonny

you do know sonny is dead right

[EliteF50]

Yes, I actually like the idea

Eww.

[batfan08]

you do know sonny is dead right

That's why i said all-star cast for batman R.I.P.,it was a sad attempt at a bad joke.

[EliteF50]

Anyone else?

[Ensanguined Walls]

Ideal Penguin:

http://www.usmagazine.com/files/verne-troyer-sex-tape-b.jpg

:lol:

[batfan08]

Walls,it's the red x.

[Jason Todd]

Lmao, Its Verne Troyer

[batfan08]

Ha,Dress him up like a gangster and he could be scarface.

[EliteF50]

Wow, I've evener seen Walls say "lol" before. :p

[Batman The Sequel Hunter]

Depp as joker!!!!!!!!

[Jables_Kage]

bane imo would need to be cgi and not a real life actor... apart from maybe the head ala juggernaut in xmen 3. depp as the riddler would be cool as he had a funny side to him as capt jack in POC. well i dont think you will beat pheffier as catwoman! and the penguin was portrayed greatly by danny devito, again to replace is gonna be hard!

[EliteF50]

I think Bane on Venom would need to be CGI, but normal Bane could be played by Dwayne.

[Jables_Kage]

Depp as joker!!!!!!!!

joker if he appears should be in the shadows and not a fully fledged person in the new film. you will not beat heaths portrayal and fans would rather see the joker dead/or never again than have someone *** it up...

[Ensanguined Walls]

joker if he appears should be in the shadows and not a fully fledged person in the new film. you will not beat heaths portrayal and fans would rather see the joker dead/or never again than have someone *** it up...

I respectfully disagree.

There are hundreds of thousands of actors in this world. Before Heath came along, it was said that Jack Nicholson's portrayal could not be bested. It's entirely possible that someone could do a much more masterful job at portraying the Joker than Heath. If you think that no actor on this earth could match the performance of one man, then I think you're approaching a level of extreme fanboyism.

[batfan08]

I really think Warner Bros. could revolutionise what CGI is capable of if they could use a full CG model and voice tracking technology.They've already begun with Arnie in T4.Wishful thinking,but it would be the ultimate tribute to Heath.

[Riddling Artist]

FIREFLY: EMINEM (yet again, The Batman firefly and just a cameo)

MR.FREEZE: VIN DIESEL (a sad hobo looking character)

HARLEY QUINN: KRISTEN BELL (main baddie at the end but doesnt get killed like twoface)

[EliteF50]

FIREFLY: EMINEM (yet again, The Batman firefly and just a cameo)

MR.FREEZE: VIN DIESEL (a sad hobo looking character)

HARLEY QUINN: KRISTEN BELL (main baddie at the end but doesnt get killed like twoface)

No offense, but if that was the cast for B3, I would go to the premier in LA only to fling poop at the director's face.

[Jables_Kage]

I respectfully disagree.

There are hundreds of thousands of actors in this world. Before Heath came along, it was said that Jack Nicholson's portrayal could not be bested. It's entirely possible that someone could do a much more masterful job at portraying the Joker than Heath. If you think that no actor on this earth could match the performance of one man, then I think you're approaching a level of extreme fanboyism.

tru but that was a different batman, to continue the joker in this line of batman films would be wrong. in like 10 yrs when we have a new batman then maybe we can think about a new joker?

[batfan08]

Patrick Stewart for Mr.Freeze ftw!

[Riddling Artist]

No offense, but if that was the cast for B3, I would go to the premier in LA only to fling poop at the director's face.

sorry. i was kinda bored. eminem would be interesting but the other ones i was kiddin. but the way i wanted the characters to be portrayed are what i would want. (kristen bell sucked in Max Payne and the only move i liked with vin diesel was pitch black)

[batfan08]

Eminem!?!

[EliteF50]

sorry. i was kinda bored. eminem would be interesting but the other ones i was kiddin. but the way i wanted the characters to be portrayed are what i would want. (kristen bell sucked in Max Payne and the only move i liked with vin diesel was pitch black)

I see. And I thought you said Kristen Dunst from Spider-man. I've never seen Bell before... until now.

WARNING: Minor cleavage
http://www.straitpinkie.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/bell6.jpg

[Riddling Artist]

Eminem!?!

yeah... itd be someone youd never expect. but hed have a cameo role at the least. why? whats wrong with eminem?

[batfan08]

guess who's back back back,back again,Firefly's back back back ...Oh noes :eek:

[Jables_Kage]

I see. And I thought you said Kristen Dunst from Spider-man. I've never seen Bell before... until now.

http://www.straitpinkie.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/bell6.jpg

nice cleavage

[Ensanguined Walls]

Kristen Bell would be a superb Harley:

http://www.heroestheseries.com/stills/kristen-bell-elle-promos-medium.jpg
http://www.mtv.com/movies/photos/f/forgetting_sarah_marshall_premiere_080411/01_kristen_bell.jpg

[batfan08]

I don't want Harley in the Nolanverse.
I could see Harleen Quinzell,just not Harley.

[EliteF50]

nice cleavage

You're right. Sorry, youngens. I added a warning.

Kristen Bell would be a superb Harley:

http://www.heroestheseries.com/stills/kristen-bell-elle-promos-medium.jpg
http://www.mtv.com/movies/photos/f/forgetting_sarah_marshall_premiere_080411/01_kristen_bell.jpg

Wow, I never thought of that. She could actually work.

[Riddling Artist]

idk it would depend. oh and the funny thing is i was singing that eminem song the other day while playing singstar against a friend. (i cant ge tit out of my head now)

[EliteF50]

idk it would depend. oh and the funny thing is i was singing that eminem song the other day while playing singstar against a friend. (i cant ge tit out of my head now)

This one? :p (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2o8UgIgI8BU)

[Ensanguined Walls]

Barack Obama: Killer Croc (pre-transformation)

http://www.funny-potato.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/12/barack-obama.jpg

[Riddling Artist]

This one? :p (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2o8UgIgI8BU)

no. its the one where he dresses like robin. (i cant post the link)

[batfan08]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hHPuRqJavo&feature=related

It is this one.

[Madav]

I respectfully disagree.

There are hundreds of thousands of actors in this world. Before Heath came along, it was said that Jack Nicholson's portrayal could not be bested. It's entirely possible that someone could do a much more masterful job at portraying the Joker than Heath. If you think that no actor on this earth could match the performance of one man, then I think you're approaching a level of extreme fanboyism.

I wouldn't go as far as to say that Heath Ledger can be topped with a "much more masterful job," but a different take on the Joker is totally plausible; as you say, Jack Nicholson was thought to have done the best portrayal and he still is by many. However, Heath Ledger (in my opinion) coincides well with Nolan's perspective on Batman's world and is the ideal antithesis to him.

I do see what you're saying though about that whole "there can be no better" approach from the more opinionated fan base.

[Riddling Artist]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hHPuRqJavo&feature=related

It is this one.

try again. ill need to find it. i like it.

[EliteF50]

Let's get back on topic, please. Anyways, more Jessica.

http://www.jessicafans.org/pics/Jessica-Alba-Looking-Hot.jpg

Not sure about you guys, but I'm seeing the future Catwoman. :p

[Riddling Artist]

no. i cant see jessica as anyone but invisible woman

[Ensanguined Walls]

Not sure about you, but I'm seeing a mediocre actress who has never done a convincing role. Being somewhat physically attractive does not automatically make someone a suitable Catwoman, and she has never impressed me in any of her roles. Catwoman's character also has depth, a sort of playfulness, and intellect. If Alba's performance in the Fantastic Four is any indication, she would fail at capturing the depth of the character.

[Riddling Artist]

found it!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QggN4XPEiRY

[EliteF50]

Not sure about you, but I'm seeing a mediocre actress who has never done a convincing role. Being somewhat physically attractive does not automatically make someone a suitable Catwoman, and she has never impressed me in any of her roles. Catwoman's character also has depth, a sort of playfulness, and intellect. If Alba's performance in the Fantastic Four is any indication, she would fail at capturing the depth of the character.

She's an actress, she can change. This is sorta like the Dwayne Johnson - Bane thing.

Dwayne has been in mediocre movies, but he has a lot of potential. So I am willing to give him a chance at Bane.

Jessica has been in mediocre movies, but she has a lot of potential. So I am willing to give her a chance at Catwoman, why can't you? You weren't against The Rock being Bane.

Sure, Dwayne has some experience that makes him suitable for the role, but that doesn't mean he can play Bane.

Get what I mean?

[Riddling Artist]

good point elite. im trying to think of someone who could play mad hatter but i cant think of anyone.

[EliteF50]

Thanks, Artist. I'm just waiting for Walls' rebuttal. :p

[Riddling Artist]

your welcome. you have any ideas for Hatter?

[EliteF50]

Hmm. Hatter... We need a short, blonde, buck-toothed guy. :\

Sorry, I've got nothing.

[scarecrow22]

Whoever played roeshack= hush, that would only work if watchmen never came out and the mask would have to never come off... I hated that movie by the way

[Riddling Artist]

Hmm. Hatter... We need a short, blonde, buck-toothed guy. :\

Sorry, I've got nothing.

im trying to think but i can only think of the guy from harry potter who plays wormtail and personally he creeps me out. ill search google!

[EliteF50]

Lol, I hope he's not Mad Hatter.

[Madav]

Eh, Jessica Alba is one of the sexiest chicks on the planet (IMO) but I'm not seeing cat woman in her; she just isn't an assertive type personality, nor is she the proper leading lady for that role - it just doesn't match. It seems as though people are pushing the envelope without knowing exactly what's inside.

This is just my opinion, but I think that Angelina Jolie is right up Cat Woman's alley. She's been in many action movies, she's played strong leading lady roles and she's got that mischievous swagger about her - a trait I think is a must for Cat Woman.

Then again, a better approach could be a lesser known figure because it adds to the notion that she's a mysterious loner and it makes sense for a masked character to not be well known.

[Riddling Artist]

Lol, I hope he's not Mad Hatter.

you and me both. what about adam sandler?

[batfan08]

Owen Wilson :D

[Riddling Artist]

Owen Wilson :D

we have a winner! i think. i cant think of anyone else... chris farley! if he were still alive.

[EliteF50]

you and me both. what about adam sandler?

Nah, he's more of a funny guy. And Owen Wilson is way too tall.

Eh, Jessica Alba is one of the sexiest chicks on the planet (IMO) but I'm not seeing cat woman in her; she just isn't an assertive type personality, nor is she the proper leading lady for that role - it just doesn't match. It seems as though people are pushing the envelope without knowing exactly what's inside.

This is just my opinion, but I think that Angelina Jolie is right up Cat Woman's alley. She's been in many action movies, she's played strong leading lady roles and she's got that mischievous swagger about her - a trait I think is a must for Cat Woman.

Then again, a better approach could be a lesser known figure because it adds to the notion that she's a mysterious loner and it makes sense for a masked character to not be well known.

The thing is, she's an actress. She can play a strong leading lady. She has great potential, and Nolan could be the one to show us all that.

Remember Keaton? There was a petition to get him out of Batman (89). Now we call him the best live-action Batman!

[Riddling Artist]

Nah, he's more of a funny guy. And Owen Wilson is way too tall.

actually i just watched TAS mad hatter and he seems pretty tall. we need a british person for hatter. Quick to the internet!

[batfan08]

I was joking,I want Steve Buscemi or Dustin Hoffman.

[EliteF50]

actually i just watched TAS mad hatter and he seems pretty tall. we need a british person for hatter. Quick to the internet!

Maybe Bale can double up? Villain and Hero? :D

[Riddling Artist]

well i did a search on google and i came up with like 2 names. (only 2 guys i saw)

daniel craig or robert pattison (and id prefer the former.)

[EliteF50]

How about Fitty?

http://youngblackhollywood.com/blog/50-cent-12.jpg

[Riddling Artist]

How about Fitty?

http://youngblackhollywood.com/blog/50-cent-12.jpg

as hatter?

[EliteF50]

Yeah, with Dr. Dre as Dr. Hugo Strange and Eminem as Firefly.

[Riddling Artist]

thats scary. i dont think id watch it. plus thered be aton of tiein raps. i want the guy who plays HOUSE to be hugo strange.

[EliteF50]

Lol, I was joking. And you're definitely right. I love that actor (no homo).

[MCREF]

Yeah, with Dr. Dre as Dr. Hugo Strange and Eminem as Firefly.

You know, Eminem as Firefly didn't sound completely crazy. And don't get your hopes up because I said it didn't sound completely crazy. He's pretty psychotic already and likes to burn things. Could work.

[EliteF50]

Lol! Well, Riddling Artist came up with the idea first.

[Riddling Artist]

Lol! Well, Riddling Artist came up with the idea first.

thanks for the credit. it fits perfectly i think. and itd be someone you wouldnt expect. hugo strange could do a psychological fight to batman

[EliteF50]

No problem. And I want someone to challenge Batman physically, like Bane. Instead of mentally, like Scarecrow and Joker.

[Riddling Artist]

good point. bu tid either want someone to test him physically and detectively. (purely detective not mental) id want to see bane but itd have to be toned down a tone. and im sure everyone wants to see kiteman.

[EliteF50]

Lol, Kiteman... He's a joke. Crazy Quilt is where it's at!

[DrCLos]

Michael Emerson for Riddler. He can play the creepy genius like nobody's business.

http://scifiwire.com/assets_c/2009/01/Lost_Emerson2-thumb-500x379-11866.jpg

[Riddling Artist]

Lol, Kiteman... He's a joke. Crazy Quilt is where it's at!

lol i watched ht ebrave and the blod episode with him as the villain.

[DrCLos]

Shave his head and Jorge Garcia would make a great Humpty Dumpty.
Jorge has already shown he can play a nice, likable guy that just happens to have a few lost marbles. This would be a small role of course.

http://www.comicbookreligion.com/img/h/Humpty_Dumpty_Dumpler.jpghttp://lostphoto.files.wordpress.com/2007/05/1b67bf0b.jpg

[DrCLos]

Michelle Rodriguez as Renee Montoya

http://www.shockya.com/news/wp-content/uploads/michelle_rodriguez_red_carpet.jpg

[EliteF50]

Updated my Bane Johnson photo:

http://i28.tinypic.com/16lbgc5.png

lol i watched ht ebrave and the blod episode with him as the villain.

Yeah... He's an extremely silly villain.

[DrCLos]

Michael Madsen as Harvey Bullock

http://www.whyfame.com/gossip/2009/june/24/michael_madsen_4_million_debt_main_10925.jpg

[batfan08]

Michelle Rodriguez as Renee Montoya

http://www.shockya.com/news/wp-content/uploads/michelle_rodriguez_red_carpet.jpg

Thank You!I was trying to think of a Spanish actress who plays those tough roles,but I couldn't think of any.

[DrCLos]

Steven Buscemi can make a cameo as Humpty Dumpty's partner, The Great White Shark.

http://www.comicbookreligion.com/img/g/Great_White_Shark.jpg
http://images.starpulse.com/Photos/pv/Steve%20Buscemi-5.jpg

[DrCLos]

Timothy Spall can look creepy enough to make a cameo as the Mad Hatter.

http://www.contactmusic.com/pics/m/sweeney_todd_premiere_5_100108/timothy_spall_5074259.jpg

[scarecrow22]

Lol, I was joking. And you're definitely right. I love that actor (no homo).

haha no homo, cockblockin *****!

[batfan08]

Michael Madsen as Harvey Bullock

http://www.whyfame.com/gossip/2009/june/24/michael_madsen_4_million_debt_main_10925.jpg

save him and Buscemi for:
Batman
By Quentin Tarantino

[DrCLos]

I think this goes without saying but Philip Seymour Hoffman would be great as the version of the Penguin who is a "legitimate business man" as a front, while doing all kinds of shady dealings in the background.

http://english.cri.cn/mmsource/images/2006/03/06/Philip-Seymour-Hoffman.jpg

[stoobytoons]

Riddler

http://aliandra.com/riddler.jpg


Jude Law


http://imagesjournal.com/2002/reviews/roadperdition/pic2.jpg

[DrCLos]

Guy Pearce could be good as Deadshot. He could be hired by the Penguin to kill Batman.

http://www.nndb.com/people/104/000026026/guy-pearce.jpg

[stoobytoons]

I should also point out that I think the whole "guy who looks like a penguin so that's how he got his name" seems a bit too convenient.
About a year ago I had the idea that perhaps a more interesting interpretation of the character would be where Oswald Cobblepot was an arms manufacturer (similar to Tony Stark) who had government contracts and was a direct competitor to Wayne Tech. The name of this company would be "Penguin Armory"; the threat would come in as he would be a supplier for local and international criminal and terrorist organizations.
I have no qualms with P-S Hoffman in the role, though I'm sure there may be more fitting actors out there.

[omerdav]

William Fichtner as new head of the mob
Kristen Bell as Harley Quinn
David Tennant as Riddler

[batfan08]

what if he got the name penguin because he wore penguin suits?

[Ensanguined Walls]

Willem Dafoe should portray the Joker after the conclusion of the Nolan series:

http://theland.antgear.com/willem_dafoe.jpg
http://images.rottentomatoes.com/images/celeb/top_100/willem_dafoe.jpg
http://nymag.com/images/2/daily/entertainment/07/09/25_dafoe_lgl.jpg
http://www4.pictures.gi.zimbio.com/Berlinale+2008+Fireflies+Garden+Press+Conference+2 haG928K-HIl.jpg
http://www2.pictures.gi.zimbio.com/Metropolitan+Opera+125th+Anniversary+Gala+BffRamjj j6pl.jpg

[stoobytoons]

what if he got the name penguin because he wore penguin suits?

You mean like giant penguin costumes? Why? Just... why??:lmao:

[DrCLos]

I should also point out that I think the whole "guy who looks like a penguin so that's how he got his name" seems a bit too convenient.
About a year ago I had the idea that perhaps a more interesting interpretation of the character would be where Oswald Cobblepot was an arms manufacturer (similar to Tony Stark) who had government contracts and was a direct competitor to Wayne Tech. The name of this company would be "Penguin Armory"; the threat would come in as he would be a supplier for local and international criminal and terrorist organizations.
I have no qualms with P-S Hoffman in the role, though I'm sure there may be more fitting actors out there.

This is actually how I pictured it as well. I actually don't think Hoffman looks like the Penguin all that much other than being portly. So I always thought the nickname would come from his arms company. Something like a code among the underworld. To keep a low profile, he'd be referred to as The Penguin instead of by Oswald.

[DrCLos]

Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje is a big guy so he could be good as Killer Croc. Just give him a skin disease and instant hired thug for The Penguin.

http://seriados.info/noticias/wp-content/adewale_akinnuoye_agbaje_18092008_.jpg

[batfan08]

You mean like giant penguin costumes? Why? Just... why??:lmao:

No,a penguin suit is a nickname for a tux.B&W

[DrCLos]

So my Penguin would have Killer Croc (the muscle) and Deadshot (sharpshooter) as hired men. Throw in Michael Pitt as Firefly for The Penguin's arsonist/explosives expert and we got a great trio for Batman to take down.

http://videodetective.com/photos/1145/04811717_.jpg

[stoobytoons]

Yes, yes, Walls. We're ALL impressed with your ability to locate Willem Dafoe in Google Images. But did you have to post so many? Me thinks someone has a crush....eh??? Seen Boondock Saints one too many times? Haha! I kid, I kid. :p

This is actually how I pictured it as well. I actually don't think Hoffman looks like the Penguin all that much other than being portly. So I always thought the nickname would come from his arms company. Something like a code among the underworld. To keep a low profile, he'd be referred to as The Penguin instead of by Oswald.

I tend to agree. He's a fine actor, don't get me wrong. But I just find him to be... I guess just not right for the part. I can't put my finger on it. I think a lot of folks are just thinking "Ok, who's a respectable actor who Chris Nolan might be on board with and who happens to be somewhat overweight?"
I think it is somewhat important to depict Cobblepot as being overweight to suggest a struggle with gluttony and greed... I mean, why else would a rich man need more money other than out of pure greed?
Who knows maybe, as you mentioned, DrCLos, "Penguin" could be the underground title and the public name of the company could be something similar like "Arctic Arms" or something like that. He, of course, should probably run the Iceberg Lounge too. ;)

[stoobytoons]

No,a penguin suit is a nickname for a tux.B&W

So, why would that set him apart from every other fat guy in a tux?

[batfan08]

Because it does.and Batman.and Robin.and Penguins.I like Penguins*sigh*

[DrCLos]

I tend to agree. He's a fine actor, don't get me wrong. But I just find him to be... I guess just not right for the part. I can't put my finger on it. I think a lot of folks are just thinking "Ok, who's a respectable actor who Chris Nolan might be on board with and who happens to be somewhat overweight?"
I think it is somewhat important to depict Cobblepot as being overweight to suggest a struggle with gluttony and greed... I mean, why else would a rich man need more money other than out of pure greed?
Who knows maybe, as you mentioned, DrCLos, "Penguin" could be the underground title and the public name of the company could be something similar like "Arctic Arms" or something like that. He, of course, should probably run the Iceberg Lounge too. ;)

I'd love to hear who you think would make a good Penguin. It's fun to do these casting things. I also thought of Timothy Spall but I think he looks way too much like a creepy penguin for the role. I would want him to look not so obvious.

And yeah I agree about the Iceberg Lounge. It would make for a great setting for Bruce Wayne to fall in love with Selina Kyle while doing recon on The Penguin.
I am having trouble thinking of a good Catwoman though. :hmm:

[DrCLos]

For Catwoman I would want someone who is a good actor and looks sexy. Megan Fox is probably a lot of people's first choice but she's not a very good actor imho. The first person that came to mind for the role was Rosario Dawson. I bet some people won't like that choice but I think it could work.

http://www.shockya.com/news/wp-content/uploads/rosario_dawson_photo.jpg

[DrCLos]

Or how about Amy Smart as Catwoman. I haven't really seen enough of her work to say if she is very good. And she doesn't have Rosario Dawson's curves.

http://www.exposay.com/celebrity-photos/amy-smart-resident-evil-extinction-world-premiere-inlas-vegas-10dhL2.jpg

[RonnyGreen]

Eddie Nashton/The Riddler
Simon Woods

http://i434.photobucket.com/albums/qq70/ominick666/SimonWoods.jpg

Jervis Tetch/The Mad Hatter
Andy Serkis
http://i124.photobucket.com/albums/p37/bragawave/AndySerkisasMr.jpg

Dr. Thomas Elliot*
Gary Sinise
http://i171.photobucket.com/albums/u320/Drea2up/Actors/gary_sinise_2401.jpg

Roman Sionis*
Simon Pegg
http://i213.photobucket.com/albums/cc257/Weremoon1/pegg-simon-cp-1240346.jpg

Selina Kyle/Catwoman
Natalia Tena
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y129/TheFlowerGirl/normal_ootpuk2007_02.jpg

*Only a cameo appearance of the characters. Who are not yet showing their villainous side.

[stoobytoons]

I'd love to hear who you think would make a good Penguin. It's fun to do these casting things. I also thought of Timothy Spall but I think he looks way too much like a creepy penguin for the role. I would want him to look not so obvious.

And yeah I agree about the Iceberg Lounge. It would make for a great setting for Bruce Wayne to fall in love with Selina Kyle while doing recon on The Penguin.
I am having trouble thinking of a good Catwoman though. :hmm:

Oh man. Well, to run a big company and love nothing but yourself and be comforted by money, you'd need a guy that could portray that fat-cat exec personality. Someone older than Bruce Wayne, for sure. Here's me spit-balling a few names.

Brian Cox
http://www.hbo.com/deadwood/img/castandcrew/actors/briancox.jpg

Brendan Gleeson
http://www.londonnet.co.uk/files/images/cinema/interviews/thetigerstail_interview2.jpg

or my personal favorite
Ray Winstone
http://videodetective.com/photos/918/038588_21.jpghttp://images.rottentomatoes.com/images/celeb/top_100/ray_winstone.jpg

Penguin's gotten a bad rap for a lot of years when I think he's got the potential to be something pretty threatening. No need for silly umbrellas (though, hidden weapons could be part of his company's product.) Somebody like Ray Winstone gives me the feeling that he could either just assume cut your jaw out or buy you a martini.
It's about personality for sure. Not just looks.

And that, for me, translates directly to Catwoman. Yeah, there's talk of Angelina Jolie. But I don't think Chris Nolan is interested in obvious choices.

Now, I've always liked Kate Beckinsale, but she's older than Christian Bale, I think. I guess a "cougar" playing Catwoman would be funny, but I dunno if that's necessary.
Megan Fox is hot, but she'd need plenty of acting classes before she filled Michelle Pfeiffer's shoes.

Odette Yustman would be my pick. She's young, a fine actress (better than Fox) and she's done a film with David Goyer and Gary Oldman recently. I could really get on board with her. :o
http://images.askmen.com/photos/odette-yustman/43431.jpg

[DrCLos]

I like Brian Cox. All your choices are good ideas though. And I completely agree about the hidden weapons thing. I imagined it that way myself. I would imagine the umbrella has to make an appearance but wouldn't be a focus or it would look silly.
I actually think Kate Beckinsale could be an awesome choice. She is definitely sexy. I don't care if she is a little older.

[RonnyGreen]

What about my suggestions?

[stoobytoons]

I like Brian Cox. All your choices are good ideas though. And I completely agree about the hidden weapons thing. I imagined it that way myself. I would imagine the umbrella has to make an appearance but wouldn't be a focus or it would look silly.
I actually think Kate Beckinsale could be an awesome choice. She is definitely sexy. I don't care if she is a little older.

Well, y'know, in The Long Halloween, Selina Kyle was the illegitimate daughter of Boss Falcone. It's no secret that Nolan and Goyer were heavily influenced by the book, so I would think that Yusman would be the perfect age and perfect look. Camera loves her, but she's got a "darkness" to her that I think goes beyond superficial sexiness into something that's deeper and interesting. I would say the same about Jude Law, though I won't say that he's "sexy." Obviously, a good-looking guy, but he's got a darkness in his eyes... almost like Michael Keaton had and was one of the determining factors for picking him as Batman.

[The Hylden]

Jesus! This thread just ballooned in a few short hours!! Well... Ok, forgive me for addressing everyone at once then :p

Patrick Stewart for Mr.Freeze ftw!

My god. You are correct, sir! The now ONLY one I can think of that can play him :D


Not sure about you, but I'm seeing a mediocre actress who has never done a convincing role. Being somewhat physically attractive does not automatically make someone a suitable Catwoman, and she has never impressed me in any of her roles. Catwoman's character also has depth, a sort of playfulness, and intellect. If Alba's performance in the Fantastic Four is any indication, she would fail at capturing the depth of the character.

Exactly.



She's an actress, she can change. This is sorta like the Dwayne Johnson - Bane thing.

Dwayne has been in mediocre movies, but he has a lot of potential. So I am willing to give him a chance at Bane.

Jessica has been in mediocre movies, but she has a lot of potential. So I am willing to give her a chance at Catwoman, why can't you? You weren't against The Rock being Bane.

Sure, Dwayne has some experience that makes him suitable for the role, but that doesn't mean he can play Bane.

Get what I mean?

Nope. What she's acted with has shown she's a mediocre actress. Whereas Dwayne Johnson – The Rock – has shown he can outdo the mediocrity of his parts. He's actually a very good actor, I think.



mad hatter and he seems pretty tall.

Uh... No. he isn't. You can get by with him played by any size, really.



How about Fitty?



Yeah, with Dr. Dre as Dr. Hugo Strange and Eminem as Firefly.

Glad I reread that as a joke:p



Michelle Rodriguez as Renee Montoya

That, I can see, however, I think Ava Mendoza would be a better choice.



Michael Madsen as Harvey Bullock


Now that's a pretty damn good choice :thumb:



Timothy Spall can look creepy enough to make a cameo as the Mad Hatter.



I can see that, sure.



think this goes without saying but Philip Seymour Hoffman would be great as the version of the Penguin who is a "legitimate business man" as a front, while doing all kinds of shady dealings in the background.


So can I. Not bad choices at all for penguin :)

Jude Law? Yes, I can see it, Stooby Toons. :)

And finally, until I find how many posts this thing has increased this time,

Odette Yustman
As Catwoman. I LOVE IT! :D She's a great actress, very agile and yes, that would be be a tremendous fit :)

[RonnyGreen]

Were they really that bad? :(

[DrCLos]

Who the heck is Ava Mendoza? I tried looking for her and couldn't find a pic. :confused:

[The Hylden]

Sorry, DrCLos, I meant Eva Mendes

Oops :p

[stoobytoons]

Jesus! This thread just ballooned in a few short hours!! Well... Ok, forgive me for addressing everyone at once then :p

I love the casting threads, what can I say.

As far as Patrick Stewart goes, I'm afraid I just don't share the enthusiasm of some of my Bat-brethren. He made a pretty great Professor X, and I think that should be the extent of his foray into the comic book film genre.

No, I would be enticed by someone less "obvious" who might dare to simply shave his head rather than go with it because he's already missing hair and has an authoritative British accent.

A tall guy. A smart guy. A guy that we KNOW can be intimidating and authoritative with just a few choice words. While I like him even better for The Riddler, I would put Hugo Weaving in the Freeze suit. The guy has the chops for solid acting AND solid action and he's very cerebral -- my main reason for considering him as Nygma.

Have a look:

http://www.fanzone50.com/Hugo/Delh.jpg

http://www.internationalhero.co.uk/s/smith1.jpg


As far as Montoya and Bullock, I think they sort of covered those characters but changed their names to Wurdts and Remirez.

[Ensanguined Walls]

I love the casting threads, what can I say.

As far as Patrick Stewart goes, I'm afraid I just don't share the enthusiasm of some of my Bat-brethren. He made a pretty great Professor X, and I think that should be the extent of his foray into the comic book film genre.

No, I would be enticed by someone less "obvious" who might dare to simply shave his head rather than go with it because he's already missing hair and has an authoritative British accent.

A tall guy. A smart guy. A guy that we KNOW can be intimidating and authoritative with just a few choice words. While I like him even better for The Riddler, I would put Hugo Weaving in the Freeze suit. The guy has the chops for solid acting AND solid action and he's very cerebral -- my main reason for considering him as Nygma.

Have a look:

http://www.fanzone50.com/Hugo/Delh.jpg

http://www.internationalhero.co.uk/s/smith1.jpg


As far as Montoya and Bullock, I think they sort of covered those characters but changed their names to Wurdts and Remirez.

What do you think of Sir Christopher Lee as the voice of Freeze?

Clip of him speaking:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNNqc4pdbNA

[DrCLos]

Personally I think Riddler should look nonthreatening physically. His "threat" comes from his genius intellect. And his craziness. I prefer Michael Emerson but Hugo Weaving isn't a bad choice either. Weaving as Mr. Freeze is also a good option.

[The Hylden]

I love the casting threads, what can I say.

As far as Patrick Stewart goes, I'm afraid I just don't share the enthusiasm of some of my Bat-brethren. He made a pretty great Professor X, and I think that should be the extent of his foray into the comic book film genre.

Why?

No, I would be enticed by someone less "obvious" who might dare to simply shave his head rather than go with it because he's already missing hair and has an authoritative British accent.

A tall guy. A smart guy. A guy that we KNOW can be intimidating and authoritative with just a few choice words. While I like him even better for The Riddler, I would put Hugo Weaving in the Freeze suit. The guy has the chops for solid acting AND solid action and he's very cerebral -- my main reason for considering him as Nygma.

Have a look:

http://www.fanzone50.com/Hugo/Delh.jpg

http://www.internationalhero.co.uk/s/smith1.jpg

While I can see it, why is this more apt than the person who so commandingly played Jean-Luc Picard? Not only that, he's just about as credited a Theater actor as you can get. I don't see how Weaving is more suitable because of his accent, surely:p Both of them are British.


As far as Montoya and Bullock, I think they sort of covered those characters but changed their names to Wurdts and Remirez.

Yeah, I figured that as well, but you never know. As the old saying goes, life is a cycle. So, perhaps you exchange one set of Gordon's men for another, yet they appear and represent just about the same things. I say this, and I actually withdraw it. For the fact I loved both of these actors in their roles and I wouldn't actually want to see them replaced.

[DrCLos]

Sorry, DrCLos, I meant Eva Mendes

Oops :p
lol oh ok. I could see that. That's a really good choice too.

[DrCLos]

I love the casting threads, what can I say.
I love these too. I am an aspiring filmmaker/tv producer so I can't really help myself. It's too much fun. :D

[The_Clown_Prince_Of_Crime]

Catwoman - Emily Blunt
The Riddler - Joseph Gordon Levitt
Penguin - Phillip Seymour Hoffman
Bane - Tyler Mane
Harley Quinn - Malin Ackerman
Killer Croc - Ron Perlman (That's not based on anything other than the fact I think he's ace & under-rated)

[Drazar]

Catwoman: Angelina Jolie
Killer Croc: Michael Clarke Duncan
Black Mask:Leonardo DiCaprio
Johnny Depp: Riddler

[The_Clown_Prince_Of_Crime]

Catwoman: Angelina Jolie
Killer Croc: Michael Clarke Duncan
Black Mask:Leonardo DiCaprio
Johnny Depp: Riddler

Whoa,good call on Michael Clarke Duncan for Killer Croc,that's pretty ace

[joker4eva]

I really think Warner Bros. could revolutionise what CGI is capable of if they could use a full CG model and voice tracking technology.They've already begun with Arnie in T4.Wishful thinking,but it would be the ultimate tribute to Heath.
youve got to think of the other actors aswell imagine how diffcult it would be to act serious when your in a seen with the joker taking to him and hes not there:)

[Drazar]

I personally hate the idea of CG Models just to make the person look like Heath Ledger. Sure he landed a oscar deserved role but really now. Its just easiest to not have the Joker in Batman 3 instead.

[stoobytoons]

Why?

Two words: "Conspiracy Theory."





While I can see it, why is this more apt than the person who so commandingly played Jean-Luc Picard? Not only that, he's just about as credited a Theater actor as you can get. I don't see how Weaving is more suitable because of his accent, surely:p Both of them are British.

I don't find Patrick Stewart to be someone who straddles the line between morally sound and strategically insane. And to suggest that a credited theatre actor should form a prerequisite for a character like Mr. Freeze really doesn't fulfill the role in my mind. If that were the case, what would keep Nathan Lane from being a suggestion? Patrick Stewart is bald.. but he's always going to be Captain of the starship Enterprise. Hey, it's unfair, but he's just not a villain to me.




Yeah, I figured that as well, but you never know. As the old saying goes, life is a cycle. So, perhaps you exchange one set of Gordon's men for another, yet they appear and represent just about the same things. I say this, and I actually withdraw it. For the fact I loved both of these actors in their roles and I wouldn't actually want to see them replaced.

Don't get me wrong. I wanted Montoya and Bullock! But maybe more as scenery and less as supporting roles. They just aren't a necessity for a perfect Batman movie. But I wouldn't argue against them if Nolan felt he wanted to add them in. :D

[GibsonSGBat]

Chuck Norris......Thats my cast.

[CaptainMcMulla]

Christian Bale (Batman)
http://thefaust.files.wordpress.com/2008/05/264298christian-bale-posters.jpg
David Tennant (Riddler)
http://community.fxuk.com/blogs/fox_insider/David-Tennant.jpg
Cillian Murphy (Scarecrow)
http://screenrant.com/wp-content/uploads/murphy.jpg

[DrCLos]

Ben Kingsley as Hugo Strange

http://worldinspiration.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/ben_kingsley.jpg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/52/ModernHugoStrange.jpg

[stoobytoons]

You guys remember the "Tattooed Prisoner" on the boat in TDK? I sort of picture him as Croc. Imagine him with with REALLY bad rash. ;)

Tommy 'Tiny' Lister
http://us.movies1.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/movie_pix/gener8xion/one_night_with_the_king/tommy__tiny__lister_jr_/king.jpg

Croc would definitely be a thug of a larger character, but I'd definitely pay to see Bats square off against this lug.

[stoobytoons]

Ben Kingsley as Hugo Strange

http://worldinspiration.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/ben_kingsley.jpg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/52/ModernHugoStrange.jpg

Yes to Kingsley!

"Meh" to Hugo Strange. Never been wild about the character, but hey, we're just fantasy casting.

[batfan08]

Due to some really awesome casting by you guys,I'm going to make some changes to my list.
Harvey Dent/Two-Face-Aaron Eckhart
Det.Harvey Bullock-Michael Madsen,(Thanks to DrClos)
Det.Renee Montoya-Michelle Rodrigez.(Again,thanks DrClos)
Selina Kyle/Catwoman-Eva Mendes(Thanks to the Hylden)
Dr.Thomas Elliot/Hush-Brad Pitt
Matt Hagen/Clayface-Ron Pearlman
Killer Croc-Andy Serkis(voice by Michael Madsen)
Victor Fries/Mr.Freeze-I still stand by my choice of Patrick Stewart(Also,for a more mechanical effect,use synthesisers on his voice)
Oswald Cobblepott/The Penguin-James Gandolfini
The Riddler/Edward Nigma-Johnny Depp(after seeing Public Enemies,he could definitely pull it off.)

[DrCLos]

I think Marcia Cross would be good for Poison Ivy. Though I see Poison Ivy as a minor character. Her MO would be poisoning her victims and she'd think she can talk to plants because she's nuts.

http://www.iamplify.com/store/images/store/1146685668404-marcia_cross.jpg

[batfan08]

I could see that.In that pic,she looks alot like Ivy from TAS.

[Game Weasel]

I'd like the third movie to be the redemption tale, the one where he wins back the hearts of the people and the GCPD. I'm going to try and keep this realistic as possible, to remain in tune with Nolan's films.
Rather than listing who I'd like to see playing a Batman character, I'm going to list which characters I believe could fit into the Nolan-verse and who I think would be a good casting pick for them.
I think the third film needs to be a story where there are a lot of other characters (villains) who appeal to the city as charismatic, enticing individuals, while Batman is feared and hated, and slowly through out the movie that situation is turned on it's ear.
With that in my mind, my cast, and their role in the film.

Hugo Strange - Ben Kingsley (Love that idea, think he's perfect for the part!)
- Dr. Hugo Strange is the new leading psychiatric doctor at Arkham Asylum, overseeing the incarceration of Gotham's strange new breed of psychopath like Jonathan Crane and Patient J. He is intrigued by these strange, costumed individuals, but the person he most wishes to examine is the Batman. He starts out as a very likable, kind, but unsettling intelligent, head-doctor; as the movie progresses he becomes so obsessed with analyzing the Batman that he becomes the very thing he's studying, a mad man.

Selina Kyle - Marion Cotillard, Angelina Jolie, or Amy Adams ( I'd have to see each one of them Audition before making my decision on who would get the part. )
-Selina Kyle is the new media darling in Gotham, she's a wealthy, intelligent, seductive philanthropist with a passion for animal rights charitys and foundations. Till now she was a complete unknown, but she has recently been spotted out on the town with Bruce Wayne and this has rocketed her up the Gotham Popularity charts as people speculate on why an intelligent woman like Selina is hanging out with a notorious playboy like Bruce Wayne.
In contrast, Batman has recently been seen around town interacting with a beautiful woman, dressed just as outlandishly as he is; in skin tight black leather with a repelling harness, a tool belt, leg pouches and numerous infiltration tools on her person. What sets her apart from the average expert thief is her cat-themed hood and lenses which begin drawing instant comparison to the Batman's, leading the papers to name her the Catwoman and speculate on whether she is Batman's partner in crime.
She spends the film trying to get this speculation to become a reality, tempting him to the dark side while he struggles to maintain his morale high ground even while the city below him curses his name.

Det. Renee Montoya - Salma Hayek
- One of the new cops hired under commissioner Jim Gordon. She and her partner, Det. Harvey Bullock (Ron Perlman) are two of the few officers Gordon trusts inside the GCPD. Throughout the movie, due to their time spent with Gordon, they come to believe Batman really is one of the good guys and they assist him and Gordon any way they can.

The Riddler - Hugo Weaving (I've long thought he'd be a great Riddler, glad I'm not the only one!)
- Edward Nigma, world reknowned chess grand master, puzzle inventer, puzzle solver, and crime buster. He's a famous private investigator who has assisted police and even the FBI on numerous occasions. His mental intellect is said to be one of the highest in the world. The papers call him the Riddler, for his famous capability with solving puzzles and riddles.
In the film he comes to Gotham to offer the GCPD his assistance in tracking down and discovering the true identity of the Batman. The film reveals that Eddie loves the spotlight, he is smart and he wants to make sure everyone realizes it; he's not in this to help Gotham City capture their masked freaks, he's in it for his own personal glory. As the films moves forward and Eddie continues to struggle to find Batman's true identity he becomes obsessed with it. Strange is obsessed with Batman's mind, and Nigma is obsessed with the face behind the mask.

The Penguin - Phillip Seymour Hoffman
- Oswald Cobblepot has recently opened up a arctic themed nightspot in Gotham, a high-class night club that all the big names from nation wide come to to see and be seen. It is frequented by the likes of Donald Trump, Bruce Wayne, Lex Luthor, and Selina Kyle.
Around the same time as Cobblepots arrival in the city the city's thugs and mobsters begin to get their hands on some powerful new hardware, military class weaponry not easily accessible to them before now. Batman soon makes a connection between the new gun smuggling ring and the arrival of Oswald in the city. He knows it's Oswald, but he spends a great deal of the movie trying to find the proof.
Oswald's charm, his tendency to wear tuxedos, and the arctic theme of his club lead the papers to give him the nickname of 'The Peguin.'

[Turn and Face the Strange]

Doesn't ANYONE want Scarecrow back? Cillian Murphy was just plain creepy!

I say again, Scarecrow (Cillian Murphy) and Riddler (David Tennant) would be awesome together.

EDIT: McMulla, thank the Lord!

[Jables_Kage]

Christian Bale (Batman)
http://thefaust.files.wordpress.com/2008/05/264298christian-bale-posters.jpg
David Tennant (Riddler)
http://community.fxuk.com/blogs/fox_insider/David-Tennant.jpg
Cillian Murphy (Scarecrow)
http://screenrant.com/wp-content/uploads/murphy.jpg

good call

[Game Weasel]

Doesn't ANYONE want Scarecrow back? Cillian Murphy was just plain creepy!

I say again, Scarecrow (Cillian Murphy) and Riddler (David Tennant) would be awesome together.

EDIT: McMulla, thank the Lord!

I loved Murphy as Crane, and I think Tennant would be a fine Riddler, I just don't want to set myself up for disappointment so I try to avoid thinking about it.
Tennant has already said he wishes to return to stage acting, that's why he's leaving Dr. Who; so I don't wanna get my hopes up to see him in any movies.
Murphy was a great 'Crow but I was honestly disappointed with the way he was used in the first movie and I don't think I really want to see Nolan use him any further.

[Polishboy]

Im surprised that nobody has considered Kate Beckinsale to play catwoman. I think she would be perfect http://www.collider.com/uploads/imageGallery/Underworld/underworld_kate_beckinsale__3_.jpg

[EliteF50]

I'm pretty sure someone mentioned her already.

[CaptainMcMulla]

Im surprised that nobody has considered Kate Beckinsale to play catwoman. I think she would be perfect http://www.collider.com/uploads/imageGallery/Underworld/underworld_kate_beckinsale__3_.jpg
wrong. it's not perfect. It's Pur-fect.

[Ensanguined Walls]

Christopher Lee (incidentally, he was in LotR with Weaving) is the only voice I would ever consider for Mr. Freeze. His voice carries such influence and power, which is essential for Freeze:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNNqc4pdbNA

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uk9AwNFFiiw&feature=PlayList&p=BCD36DE5A917D068&index=0&playnext=1

http://blogs.coventrytelegraph.net/thegeekfiles/Saruman1.jpg

[Zombie-Gamer]

Mad Hatter - Mackenzie Crook
http://img2.allposters.com/images/MMPH/258189.jpg

Mr Freeze - Patrick Stewart
http://stng.36el.com/st-tng/cast/images/stewart.jpg

Catwoman - Kate Beckinsale (Whooo Underworld fan!)
http://www.mohammadi.ca/media/1/20070526-normal_007.jpg

I don't know about the Riddler personally I think every eles pick of either david tennant or Johnny Depp would be great.

The Joker - Willem Dafoe Of course!
http://www.caffepedrocchi.it/get_img_photogallery.php?id=94&format=contenuto_testuale

I'd love to see Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy but I haven't seen anyone I'd like as Ivy.

[Ensanguined Walls]

Underworld is only worth watching for Bill Nighy's performance as Viktor, IMO.

[ambush king]

yummy i love me some old school Kate



I love the way you hold my Coke baby.

http://www.gceleb.com/pictures-2/kate_beckinsale/kate-beckinsale-3.jpg

[Zombie-Gamer]

Underworld is only worth watching for Bill Nighy's performance as Viktor, IMO.

I love them! :D and Bill Nighy is awesome as Viktor. But yeah Back to Batman.... Bil Nighy would be good as someone any ideas?
O how bout Bill Nighy as Bazil Karlo old actor who becomes Clayface.

[cpmd4]

Helena Bonham Carter as Harley Quinn, please.

Phillip Seymour Hoffman as Penguin and Johnny Depp as Riddler are great choices too.

[Zombie-Gamer]

Helena Bonham Carter as Harley Quinn, please.

Phillip Seymour Hoffman as Penguin and Johnny Depp as Riddler are great choices too.

I love Helena Bonham Carter but I don't see her as Harley, tho if she did play her it would be awesome
If Tim Burton ever returned as director Depp would be the Riddler and Carter would be Harley :D

[Gallagher]

Helena Bonham Carter as Harley Quinn, please.

Phillip Seymour Hoffman as Penguin and Johnny Depp as Riddler are great choices too.
This is spot on imo. I actually think Helena could pull off an amazing Harley. She has that beautiful yet creepy look.

EDIT: Not sure if that last picture was a bit too exposing, just google her if you don't know who it is.

[KnowHowIGotTheseScars?]

I think this goes without saying but Philip Seymour Hoffman would be great as the version of the Penguin who is a "legitimate business man" as a front, while doing all kinds of shady dealings in the background.

http://english.cri.cn/mmsource/images/2006/03/06/Philip-Seymour-Hoffman.jpg

This is the best casting I think ..... I was a rumor that was confirmed as being not true by Hoffman himself

BUT HE WOULD COMPLETELY DOMINATE THAT ROLE

[EliteF50]

Didn't Nolan already say he's not going to do a story about Penguin?

[KnowHowIGotTheseScars?]

Its just my opinion .... He's an amazing actor and I think he could really blow that roll out of the water

[Velderik]

Didn't Nolan already say he's not going to do a story about Penguin?

Too bad, really would like to see Danny Devito again as the Penguin.

http://manolobig.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/penguin.jpg

[Drazar]

Didn't Nolan already say he's not going to do a story about Penguin?

The real question is, does he know what Penquin is? Alot of directors and actors sometimes do believe that examples such as Jim Carey's Riddler or Danny Devito's Penquin are 100% the same as their comic counterparts. So it does make me wonder does he know what the real Penquin is. =X

[Velderik]

The real question is, does he know what Penquin is? Alot of directors and actors sometimes do believe that examples such as Jim Carey's Riddler or Danny Devito's Penquin are 100% the same as their comic counterparts. So it does make me wonder does he know what the real Penquin is. =X

I really liked how they portraited the Penguin in Batman Returns, maybe it's different than the one from the comics but he still did a great job.
Didn't really like Jim Carey as the Riddler, he acted the same way as he did in Ace Ventura, he was way too hyper if you ask me.

+

"The Penguin is set to be in Batman: Arkham Asylum, voiced by David Sobolov"

I didn't know this, is that guy any good ?

[Ensanguined Walls]

I really liked how they portraited the Penguin in Batman Returns, maybe it's different than the one from the comics but he still did a great job.
Didn't really like Jim Carey as the Riddler, he acted the same way as he did in Ace Ventura, he was way too hyper if you ask me.

+

"The Penguin is set to be in Batman: Arkham Asylum, voiced by David Sobolov"

I didn't know this, is that guy any good ?

Sorry, that's untrue. I e-mailed David, and he said he's not involved with Arkham Asylum.

[EliteF50]

Too bad, really would like to see Danny Devito again as the Penguin.

http://manolobig.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/penguin.jpg

Agreed. No one can top Danny's performance.

[Velderik]

Sorry, that's untrue. I e-mailed David, and he said he's not involved with Arkham Asylum.

Another dream smashed to pieces :(
But hey, there's still hope for the Penguin as a DLC.

[stoobytoons]

Im surprised that nobody has considered Kate Beckinsale to play catwoman. I think she would be perfect http://www.collider.com/uploads/imageGallery/Underworld/underworld_kate_beckinsale__3_.jpg

Are you kidding? I suggested her like 2 pages ago. And then 2 or 3 years ago elsewhere.

[Riddling Artist]

ive noticd that people are picking alot of people who look so much like the actual character (ben kingsley as hugo starange for example) i mean im pretty sure noone saw heath ledger as the joker:D but im gonna want the guy from house as hugo strange. he just seems so doctorish and always planning to me.

[Ensanguined Walls]

Michael Sheen - Mad Hatter

http://www.thehollywoodnews.com/artman2/uploads/1/michael-sheen.jpg
http://images.mirror.co.uk/upl/m4/dec2008/4/9/88C69D7C-A671-E8EB-2852CD9F0C791C1A.jpg
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3062/3083047636_478cc52af1.jpg

(Incidentally, Sheen was married to Kate Beckinsale and had a daughter with her.)

[Riddling Artist]

^ probably the closest ive seen for an actor for mad hatter (just die his hair na make his teeth crooked but dont make him insane. (i hated that depiction of hatter in the long halloween and dark victory. my favorite hatter was TAS)

[batfan08]

Jervis Tetch isn't a snaggletooth you know.In fact,I've never seen a version where his teeth were crooked.a little large,but not crooked,also,why does he have to have blonde hair?His hair in Arkham is red(see concept art).Seriously,he doesn't have to be just like TAS.

On a side note,now that he's older,I really think Danny Devito would make a fantastic businessman penguin.

[Riddling Artist]

i wasnt saying he was snaggletoothed. just a bit crooked. not a ton. and i said blonde hair cuz of TAS. his hairs blonde in TAS. hey whered you find concept art of him?

[batfan08]

on the reecio picture thread.

[Riddling Artist]

i found it. but id rather have the mad hatter blonde without muttonchops.

[batfan08]

No more Blonde Mad Hatters!.You know that there are more versions than TAS,right?

[Riddling Artist]

No more Blonde Mad Hatters!.You know that there are more versions than TAS,right?

nope.:D im mad i tell you. mad! and how many blonde mad hatters are there? (an dwhile im at it how many blonde haired characters are there in the nolanverse?)

[stoobytoons]

No more Blonde Mad Hatters!.You know that there are more versions than TAS,right?

What versions didn't have blonde, red, or strawberry blonde hair?:confused:

http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/Batman/images/7/7f/Mad_hatter.jpg

http://www.bat-mania.co.uk/main/villains/images/madhatter.jpg

http://www.i-mockery.com/comics/longbox15/pics/mad-hatter.jpg

[Riddling Artist]

What versions didn't have blonde, red, or strawberry blonde hair?:confused:

exactly my point. although there was one with grey hair but thats the one i like the least.

[stoobytoons]

exactly my point. although there was one with grey hair but thats the one i like the least.

I'm not sure hair color is a definitive characteristic of any Batman character other than the Joker. So, what's the big deal?

[Riddling Artist]

I'm not sure hair color is a definitive characteristic of any Batman character other than the Joker. So, what's the big deal?

well... hmm... poison ivy has definative hair:D lol but id prefer the mad hatter to be blonde. it gives him that approachable evil look. ( like TAS :D just kidding)

[stoobytoons]

well... hmm... poison ivy has definative hair:D lol but id prefer the mad hatter to be blonde. it gives him that approachable evil look. ( like TAS :D just kidding)

Maybe so. But, I would be perfectly fine with a blonde, or brown-haired Ivy, just as I came around with a Joker that puts on make-up. I guess to borrow the phrase somewhat, "It's not who you are (on the surface), but what you do that defines you."

[Riddling Artist]

maybe so. But, i would be perfectly fine with a blonde, or brown-haired ivy, just as i came around with a joker that puts on make-up. I guess to borrow the phrase somewhat, "it's not who you are (on the surface), but what you do that defines you."

!!!!! Bruce? :D

[stoobytoons]

!!!!! Bruce? :D

*turns**jumps**savestheday*:cool:

[Riddling Artist]

*turns**jumps**savestheday*:cool:

lol at least you dont get blown up in TDK:D

[stoobytoons]

lol at least you dont get blown up in TDK:D

As far as you know. hehe

[Riddling Artist]

As far as you know. hehe

soo you think rachel isnt dead.:scratch:

[batfan08]

She drags Harvey into the sewer at the end of TDk and saves his life.They are then married by a preacher rat and become Harvey Two-Face and Rachel No-Face.Fin.

[Riddling Artist]

She drags Harvey into the sewer at the end of TDk and saves his life.They are then married by a preacher rat and become Harvey Two-Face and Rachel No-Face.Fin.

yay! a happy ending. im so happy im about to cry...:rolleyes: heres my plot for the next batman movie... jingle bells... robin smells... the batmobile lost a whell... and joker gets away. emmy gold if you ask me.

[batfan08]

you mean Oscar.The emmys are for T.E.L.E.V.I.S.O.N :)

[Riddling Artist]

you mean Oscar.The emmys are for T.E.L.E.V.I.S.O.N :)

who said it was gonna be in thatres?

[batfan08]

JarJar Binks did.

[Riddling Artist]

JarJar Binks did.

greaat...speaking of which. JAR JAR BINKS IS THE RIDDLER. yousa riddle meesa thisa.

[batfan08]

Anyway,we should get back on topic so the thread doesn't get locked.Who do you think would be a good Penguin?

[stoobytoons]

I think we sort of touched on Penguin a few pages back. Mind if we switch gears a bit?

Let's get down to Poison Ivy. There hasn't really been a GREAT suggestion for her yet. Anyone?

Obviously beautiful, but an actress with a definitive dark side would be perfect!

[batfan08]

what about Helena Bonham Carter?

[stoobytoons]

what about Helena Bonham Carter?

Well... yeah. I think she's got the right level of "darkness" but I'm not sure she's quite got that certain something needed as far as physical beauty. She's a pretty lady, don't get me wrong, but I don't see her as Ivy.

This is killing me because I noticed an actress weeks ago that I thought would be perfect and I was going to suggest it to you guys back then but I've completely forgotten. :mad2:

[batfan08]

Hey,it happens to all of us,Stooby.Sometimes,I wonder what my name is.

[omerdav]

Sorry folks, i think that if they'll want Ivy in nolan's film series (hugetastic mistake), they'll have to CGI.

[EliteF50]

Sorry folks, i think that if they'll want Ivy in nolan's film series (hugetastic mistake), they'll have to CGI.

Why?

[Game Weasel]

Sorry folks, i think that if they'll want Ivy in nolan's film series (hugetastic mistake), they'll have to CGI.

What makes you say that? Nolan's gone out of his way to avoid super powers in his characters, they're all 'real world' versions so if Ivy's in a film of his she certainly won't be controlling plants, she'll probably be like a botanist/toxicologist who becomes an eco-terrorist.

I still stand by Christina Hendricks as my choice for Isley, you have to have seen her perform to understand it but she's got the talent to play a magnificent Isley.
http://theryancokeexperience.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/christina-hendricks.jpg
She's best known for her role as Joan Holloway on Mad Men, Winner of A Best Drama Actress award as well as one of the winners of the Screen Actor's Guild best ensemble cast performance award in 2007
The group was nominated again in 2008.

[KillerCroc]

She would make a good Posion Ivy, I have to get around watching Mad Men. But anyways, better picture of her I have to say. It won me over. :p

[DrCLos]

What makes you say that? Nolan's gone out of his way to avoid super powers in his characters, they're all 'real world' versions so if Ivy's in a film of his she certainly won't be controlling plants, she'll probably be like a botanist/toxicologist who becomes an eco-terrorist.

I still stand by Christina Hendricks as my choice for Isley, you have to have seen her perform to understand it but she's got the talent to play a magnificent Isley.
http://theryancokeexperience.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/christina-hendricks.jpg
She's best known for her role as Joan Holloway on Mad Men, Winner of A Best Drama Actress award as well as one of the winners of the Screen Actor's Guild best ensemble cast performance award in 2007
The group was nominated again in 2008.


Good pick. I have never seen Mad Men but she did cross my mind for Poison Ivy. I just didn't know if she could act or not. I think she has the right look. :thumb:

[Ensanguined Walls]

I found an intriguing choice for the Riddler. How about Ralph Fiennes?

http://celebrity-pics.movieeye.com/celebrity_pictures/Ralph_Fiennes_618267.jpg
http://img2.timeinc.net/ew/dynamic/imgs/060112/143331__fiennes_l.jpg
http://img5.allocine.fr/acmedia/rsz/434/x/x/x/medias/nmedia/18/36/00/53/18457393.jpg
http://wetmen.provocateuse.com/images/photos/ralph_fiennes_01.jpg
http://accidentalsexiness.files.wordpress.com/2008/11/ralph-fiennes.jpg

[Zombie-Gamer]

http://theryancokeexperience.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/christina-hendricks.jpg


Wow she's beautiful.
and as for Ralph Fiennes that man scares me deeply. :D

[stoobytoons]

What makes you say that? Nolan's gone out of his way to avoid super powers in his characters, they're all 'real world' versions so if Ivy's in a film of his she certainly won't be controlling plants, she'll probably be like a botanist/toxicologist who becomes an eco-terrorist.

I still stand by Christina Hendricks as my choice for Isley, you have to have seen her perform to understand it but she's got the talent to play a magnificent Isley.
http://theryancokeexperience.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/christina-hendricks.jpg
She's best known for her role as Joan Holloway on Mad Men, Winner of A Best Drama Actress award as well as one of the winners of the Screen Actor's Guild best ensemble cast performance award in 2007
The group was nominated again in 2008.



Well, she certainly looks like an Ivy. But I haven't seen Mad Men, so I can't quite say one way or the other. I do agree with your comment about the eco-terrorist thing. I've always thought it would be interesting to bring back the "little blue flower" that Crane used for his fear toxin and connect it with Ivy.:thumb:

[EliteF50]

I hope Bale signs on for another three movies, even if Nolan isn't the director.

[Riddling Artist]

^ idk she seems a bit too playful to be ivy (just by looking at the pic.) and i havent watched mad men either. so idk... how bout umu thurman? ( probably wrong)

[Riddling Artist]

I hope Bale signs on for another three movies, even if Nolan isn't the director.

yeah... cuz we all want to see bat nipples with a gravely voice:rolleyes: just kidding. but id watch a batman movie if zack snyder was in charge.

[EliteF50]

yeah... cuz we all want to see bat nipples with a gravely voice:rolleyes: just kidding. but id watch a batman movie if zack snyder was in charge.

Well, I meant I hope the next director casts Bale as Batman... If Bale still wants to do it, of course.

[Riddling Artist]

bales a good batman but im pretty sure i couldnt deal with gravelvoice 3. the return of gravel voice. but id want to see bale do more batman.

[EliteF50]

Oh, and something tells me she'd be a bit too... distracting to play Ivy.

[Riddling Artist]

Oh, and something tells me she'd be a bit too... distracting to play Ivy.

yeah. i know what you mean. i just cant lay my finger on it.... its her ears. it has to be the ears.:rolleyes:

[EliteF50]

bales a good batman but im pretty sure i couldnt deal with gravelvoice 3. the return of gravel voice. but id want to see bale do more batman.

It's not Bale's fault, it's the sound editors' fault. They wanted to make him sound "scarier."

Bale did the voice exactly how he did it in Batman Begins. No one complained about that.

yeah. i know what you mean. i just cant lay my finger on it.... its her ears. it has to be the ears.:rolleyes:

Lol.

[Riddling Artist]

lol stupid sound editors. why couldnt they just keep to making the scarecrow sounding scary?

[EliteF50]

Exactly. And another issue I had with TDK was how they made Scarecrow a thug in a mask. It would have been cool if he had more screen time.

[DrCLos]

I also think Scarlett Johansson could make a graet Poison Ivy. She is already playing a sexy redhead as Black Widow for Iron Man 2.

http://www.aceshowbiz.com/images/events/DGG-021399.jpg

[DrCLos]

Javier Bardem would be good as Cameron van Cleer aka Killer Moth. But not wearing that garish outfit from the comics. Instead he'd be a fellow billionaire philanthropist who befriends Bruce Wayne.

In his spare time, Cameron likes to kill people because he is insane. Cameron uses his large pockets to begin developing gadgets to torture and kill his victims. He pins a dead moth on his victims as a calling card, which leads the police to refer to him as Killer Moth.

http://hissip.files.wordpress.com/2008/03/javierba.jpg

[Game Weasel]

I also think Scarlett Johansson could make a graet Poison Ivy. She is already playing a sexy redhead as Black Widow for Iron Man 2.

http://www.aceshowbiz.com/images/events/DGG-021399.jpg

Scarlett could work, but I think she's a little to sweet looking for it. I could see her as Harley before I could see her as Ivy. Ivy's usually an older and slightly more intimidatingly beautiful woman.

[Dark Cape]

I think that Isla Fisher could be good as Poison Ivy.

[Riddling Artist]

Javier Bardem would be good as Cameron van Cleer aka Killer Moth. But not wearing that garish outfit from the comics. Instead he'd be a fellow billionaire philanthropist who befriends Bruce Wayne.

In his spare time, Cameron likes to kill people because he is insane. Cameron uses his large pockets to begin developing gadgets to torture and kill his victims. He pins a dead moth on his victims as a calling card, which leads the police to refer to him as Killer Moth.

http://hissip.files.wordpress.com/2008/03/javierba.jpg

maybe. it could work. but id prefer a cameo of the police taking killer moth to arkhem. he could hav his famous stripe pantts. or stripe tattos.

[DrCLos]

Scarlett could work, but I think she's a little to sweet looking for it. I could see her as Harley before I could see her as Ivy. Ivy's usually an older and slightly more intimidatingly beautiful woman.

I also think she could be Barbara Gordon.

[omerdav]

Why?
i just don't see her character played respectfully. even if treated as ecco terrorist. it will fall to cliches, sort of like thurman did.

[stoobytoons]

http://hissip.files.wordpress.com/2008/03/javierba.jpg

Y'know? I'd much rather see Bardem as Bane or even Mr. Freeze. Using pro wrestlers for the guy just didn't work the first time around.

I like the Isla Fischer idea... then again she might be better as Harley.:nut:

[The Hylden]

I'm not going back to quote everyone, but there are some really good choices that have sprung up. Kate Beckinsale as Catwoman = absolute yes :thumb: She's probably the best, or close to, actresses going and she's continually delivered in the Underworld movies. And Christina Hendricks there for Ivy is not bad. Haven't seen her work, but she looks the part. Why wouldn't she work? What's wrong with her?! She's beautiful. She's got ... HUGE ... tracks of land! :p

[Game Weasel]

I'm not going back to quote everyone, but there are some really good choices that have sprung up. Kate Beckinsale as Catwoman = absolute yes :thumb: She's probably the best, or close to, actresses going and she's continually delivered in the Underworld movies. And Christina Hendricks there for Ivy is not bad. Haven't seen her work, but she looks the part. Why wouldn't she work? What's wrong with her?! She's beautiful. She's got ... HUGE ... tracks of land! :p

:rolleyes:

I wish someoen here had seen her in something so they could back me up on why I think she's perfect for the part beyond just being gorgeous. :p

[DrCLos]

Here you go. Scarlett Johansson as Barbara Gordon.

http://www.411mania.com/siteimages/ironmanscarlettnew_24997.jpg

[DrCLos]

Christopher Eccleston could be a good Black Mask.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_eP-TQH6WbX0/SC5lmVnU-fI/AAAAAAAADZ8/iEx0jCl_9SA/s400/G.I.%2BJoe%2BMovie%2B-%2BChristopher%2BEccleston%2Bas%2BDestro%2B3.jpg

[door noob]

Here you go. Scarlett Johansson as Barbara Gordon.

You know if Christopher Nolan directs the thirs film it'll be in the same year as The Dark knight or a year later and Barbara is still a kid that's like 8yrs old as we have seen.

[DrCLos]

You know if Christopher Nolan directs the thirs film it'll be in the same year as The Dark knight or a year later and Barbara is still a kid that's like 8yrs old as we have seen.

I'm no longer doing this as my ideal Batman 3. It's just fun to cast the various Batman characters. I think Scarlett could be a good Barbara Gordon. That is all.

[door noob]

I'm no longer doing this as my ideal Batman 3. It's just fun to cast the various Batman characters. I think Scarlett could be a good Barbara Gordon. That is all.

Oh, ok then and ya she would :D

[stoobytoons]

Christopher Eccleston could be a good Black Mask.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_eP-TQH6WbX0/SC5lmVnU-fI/AAAAAAAADZ8/iEx0jCl_9SA/s400/G.I.%2BJoe%2BMovie%2B-%2BChristopher%2BEccleston%2Bas%2BDestro%2B3.jpg

I like it! So long as he is less corny than in Gone in 60 Seconds.

[Gho-Gerhowev]

Daniel Day-Lewis would be an awesome Black Mask, anyone agree?

http://socialitelife.celebuzz.com/images/2007/12/there_will_be_blood_121107_0001.jpg

http://25frames.org/media/news/daniel_day-lewis.jpg

[The Hylden]

Daniel Day-Lewis would probably be a good anything, and a great most things ;)

"I ... drink your milkshake! I drink it up!"

Edit: Christopher Eccleston = a great Doctor Who, and a really good seething power-mongering Commander of a post-apocalyptic England in 28 Days Later :) With good material, he can do great things.

[NotNamedJohn]

John Malkovich as Hugo Strange.
David Tennant as The Riddler.
David Hyde Pierce as The Clock King (I highly doubt Clock King would be in the movie, but still, in one picture of him it looks like he's trying to be the Clock King).

I have bunches more but I can't remember all of them right now... I'll have to sift through the dozens of other threads with casting ideas. >.<

[DarkKnightDanny]

Daniel Day-Lewis would probably be a good anything, and a great most things ;)

"I ... drink your milkshake! I drink it up!"

Edit: Christopher Eccleston = a great Doctor Who, and a really good seething power-mongering Commander of a post-apocalyptic England in 28 Days Later :) With good material, he can do great things.

"i driiiink it up!"

what a brilliant role.

[AGENTIS 47]

I'm on the Depp bandwagon, he's easily my favorite actor and I think he would make an amazing Riddler.

Philip Seymour Hoffman could definitely pull off Penguin.

thats wht i think Phillip Seymour Hoffman could pull off the Penguin...
and Johnny Depp could play the Riddler

[JokerJr.]

I think Jim Carrey should play the riddler again.

[JokerJr.]

i agree w/ kage but they should at least give the joker a cameo like show him in the asylum or something

[ShayShay1993]

im not sure if im bringing the dead back or not, but what about Halle Berry as Catwoman again?

[The Hylden]

I think Jim Carrey should play the riddler again.

im not sure if im bringing the dead back or not, but what about Halle Berry as Catwoman again?

I think you two are made for each other... :rolleyes:

[The Comedian]

http://weblogs.newsday.com/news/local/longisland/politics/blog/george-w-bush-picture.jpeg

for Joker, after all he is a criminal mastermind. Trust the Comedian fellas.

[CaptainMcMulla]

http://weblogs.newsday.com/news/local/longisland/politics/blog/george-w-bush-picture.jpeg

for Joker, after all he is a criminal mastermind. Trust the Comedian fellas.
oh, he's the best joker ever. even better than mark hamill.

[WillXW]

Poison Ivy: Eva Mendes
Harley Quinn: ???
Catwoman: Never Ever - Michelle Phiffer the only Catwoman
Penguin: Ricky Gervais
Riddler: Ricky Gervais, Eddie or Steve Carell - I can imagine Batman getting stumped by his riddles and Gervais insulting him

[stoobytoons]

http://weblogs.newsday.com/news/local/longisland/politics/blog/george-w-bush-picture.jpeg

for Joker, after all he is a criminal mastermind. Trust the Comedian fellas.

http://www.payvand.com/news/08/may/Barack-Obama.jpg

Sweet! And let's roll in a new Black Mask candidate, shall we?

How about zipping the political commentary though? :rolleyes:

[The Comedian]

http://www.payvand.com/news/08/may/Barack-Obama.jpg

Sweet! And let's roll in a new Black Mask candidate, shall we?

How about zipping the political commentary though? :rolleyes:

*cough* racism *cough*

[ChristianBaleBatman]

...this is awkward...

[Perfect Moo]

Peter Stormare as the Joker.

http://www.lahiguera.net/cinemania/actores/peter_stormare/fotos/3763/peter_stormare.jpg

Yes, the dude from prison break.

Johnny Depp as the Riddler.

No picture needed.

[Perfect Moo]

what about Helena Bonham Carter?

That's the one chick from Terminator: Salvation!

[Hook1123]

Christan Bale Batman Mark Hamill MAYBE Joker??? Johnny Depp as The Riddler???

[Joe Chill]

Some of the best ideas I've heard so far are:

David Tennant as The Riddler, though I had never heard of him before. He definitely has the look to go with it, though, and I'm sure Nolan could bring out the narcissist in him. lol

Christina Hendricks as Poison Ivy. I must admit I wasn't familiar with her, either, but she already looks good with red hair, so they wouldn't have to attempt to change an actresses hair color in a bad way (i.e. Kirsten Dunst in the Spiderman films).

I also think Scarlett Johanssen would be a perfect Harely Quinn as far as the look goes, but I'm not sure if she has the bubbly personality needed to pull it off.

I also want to know why everyone thinks Johnny Depp would be such a good Edward Nygma/Riddler. I'm not necessarily disagreeing with you, but would just like an explanation. And, oh God, Dwayne Johnson as Bane would just have to end up being way too corny. I'm not sure of Hoffman as the Penguin, either---I still think it's just a rumor.

Nolan's direction in his films has always seemed to have been to choose not "blockbuster" actors, which I think has worked out well, so far.

I don't think any sidekicks are needed, now, either. Plus, as has been said...it wouldn't really fit it with the time of the storyline.

[Batfan22]

Some of the best ideas I've heard so far are:

David Tennant as The Riddler, though I had never heard of him before. He definitely has the look to go with it, though, and I'm sure Nolan could bring out the narcissist in him. lol

Christina Hendricks as Poison Ivy. I must admit I wasn't familiar with her, either, but she already looks good with red hair, so they wouldn't have to attempt to change an actresses hair color in a bad way (i.e. Kirsten Dunst in the Spiderman films).

I also think Scarlett Johanssen would be a perfect Harely Quinn as far as the look goes, but I'm not sure if she has the bubbly personality needed to pull it off.

I also want to know why everyone thinks Johnny Depp would be such a good Edward Nygma/Riddler. I'm not necessarily disagreeing with you, but would just like an explanation. And, oh God, Dwayne Johnson as Bane would just have to end up being way too corny. I'm not sure of Hoffman as the Penguin, either---I still think it's just a rumor.

Nolan's direction in his films has always seemed to have been to choose not "blockbuster" actors, which I think has worked out well, so far.

I don't think any sidekicks are needed, now, either. Plus, as has been said...it wouldn't really fit it with the time of the storyline.

about depp being riddler hes just areally great and well known actor and i think has the talent to best ledgers performance. andhe defanitly can fit the character because he plays such a wide variety of rolls he can pretty much do anything

[Joe Chill]

about depp being riddler hes just areally great and well known actor and i think has the talent to best ledgers performance. andhe defanitly can fit the character because he plays such a wide variety of rolls he can pretty much do anything

That's what I keep hearing from people, but help me understand more---give me some examples.

[Joe Chill]

Am I the only one that thinks Croc would be a good addition to the new Batman film? He's dark, scary, and offers a new challenge the Dark Knight has yet to face---super strength/physical abilities.

I know that Nolan had mentioned something one time about not wanting to do a lot of CGI on a character, but Two-Face looked amazing in TDK, and it's not like Killer Croc would have to be the main villain---he could be lurking in the sewers where Batman ends up catching him near the end of the film before going to face The Riddler/Mr. Freeze/etc.

Sorry for the double post.

[EliteF50]

I just want Bane. They wouldn't need any CGI for him, and he offers a fresh twist to the Nolan-Universe. There hasn't been a villain that physically challenges Batman,yet.

[WillXW]

Everyone is just suggesting anyone tbh.

We need actors who are good at acting, at the top of their league and have tons of experience, look the part and have that good-looks appeal.

Eva Mendes for Poison Ivy because she has been in tons of films ranging from action, romance, comedy, adventure. She is sexy and attractive and looks like Poison Ivy.

http://xrayvision.today.com/files/2009/02/poison-ivy-batman-robin.png

Ricky Jervais for Riddler or Penguin

Michelle Phiffer for Catwoman - actors normally play younger roles

Sarah Jane Dunn who actually played Harley Quinn in TDK / Maroni's Mistress

[Joe Chill]

I've never been surrounded by so many Bane fans! lol

I think if they wanted to do Bane right, they would need to touch up some areas with CGI, but you're right, he still wouldn't be based on computer imaging, anyway.

What I like about Nolan's films is that we don't have to sit through the "how the villains became the way they are" segments. I mean, Scarecrow was already Scarecrow in BB, and the Joker was the same way in TDK, so really we could just have any villain in a film that we want to see and it not be a problem.

[WillXW]

Everyone is just suggesting anyone tbh.

We need actors who are good at acting, at the top of their league and have tons of experience, look the part and have that good-looks appeal.

Eva Mendes for Poison Ivy because she has been in tons of films ranging from action, romance, comedy, adventure. She is sexy and attractive and looks like Poison Ivy.

http://xrayvision.today.com/files/2009/02/poison-ivy-batman-robin.png

Ricky Jervais for Riddler or Penguin

Michelle Phiffer for Catwoman - actors normally play younger roles

Sarah Jane Dunn who actually played Harley Quinn in TDK / Maroni's Mistress

Patrick Stewart would be perfect as he's old and he's a veteran actor able to deliver an earth-shattering performance.

[EliteF50]

I've never been surrounded by so many Bane fans! lol

I think if they wanted to do Bane right, they would need to touch up some areas with CGI, but you're right, he still wouldn't be based on computer imaging, anyway.

What I like about Nolan's films is that we don't have to sit through the "how the villains became the way they are" segments. I mean, Scarecrow was already Scarecrow in BB, and the Joker was the same way in TDK, so really we could just have any villain in a film that we want to see and it not be a problem.

Exactly. Personally, I hate that we don't see their origins, but that's the way Nolan likes it. He also changed the origins for every one of his characters.

So, my guess is that if Nolan makes B3 with Bane, there won't be Venom, he won't be South American, and he won't break Batman's back.

[Joe Chill]

Everyone is just suggesting anyone tbh.

We need actors who are good at acting, at the top of their league and have tons of experience, look the part and have that good-looks appeal.

Eva Mendes for Poison Ivy because she has been in tons of films ranging from action, romance, comedy, adventure. She is sexy and attractive and looks like Poison Ivy.

http://xrayvision.today.com/files/2009/02/poison-ivy-batman-robin.png

Ricky Jervais for Riddler or Penguin

Michelle Phiffer for Catwoman - actors normally play younger roles

Sarah Jane Dunn who actually played Harley Quinn in TDK / Maroni's Mistress

Ugh...Eva Mendes MIGHT be a good Poison Ivy, but I just can't see her in that role. I fear that if we get actors "popular with teenagers" or "sex symbols" to fill these roles, that's what eventually takes us to Joel Schmaker's script library.

Ricky Jervais? I'm not familiar with his work, but I don't see any one person being able to be Riddler or Penguin---the two characters are just too different.

Michelle Phiffer again? haha...I don't see this happening at all. I don't think she'd be up to the part, and I know that everyone who grew up in that era absolutely fell in love with her in the role, but it's time for a new generation Catwoman (and I don't mean Halle Berry).

Harely Quinn was in TDK? Wait...what?

[DrCLos]

The idea of Christina Hendricks as Poison Ivy has grown on me a lot. I don't care if she is a little thick. She is the sexiest red head on TV.

http://www.411mania.com/siteimages/curvyhendricks2_26027.jpg

[Termix]

Not sure about you, but I'm seeing a mediocre actress who has never done a convincing role. Being somewhat physically attractive does not automatically make someone a suitable Catwoman, and she has never impressed me in any of her roles. Catwoman's character also has depth, a sort of playfulness, and intellect. If Alba's performance in the Fantastic Four is any indication, she would fail at capturing the depth of the character.

Yeah Jessica Alba was acting perfect when she was invisible :>
and i vote for Halle Berry as Catwoman!



just joking, good cast would be:
Scarlett Johansson as Catwoman
Dwayne Johnson as Bane
Christian Bale as Batman
Will Smith as Killer Croc (sry no joke here)

[stoobytoons]

The idea of Christina Hendricks as Poison Ivy has grown on me a lot. I don't care if she is a little thick. She is the sexiest red head on TV.

http://www.411mania.com/siteimages/curvyhendricks2_26027.jpg

....I want to go to there. :eek:

[Game Weasel]

So thrilled to see so many folks agree with my Hendricks as Ivy idea. :D
I really think she could knock that one right out of the park.

[Joe Chill]

just joking, good cast would be:
Scarlett Johansson as Catwoman
Dwayne Johnson as Bane
Christian Bale as Batman
Will Smith as Killer Croc (sry no joke here)

Well, you're halfway right. Of course Bale would be a good Batman, again. I also agree that Johansson could be a good Catwoman.

There is no way that The Rock would be a good Bane. Really, I don't see how (plus it will never happen). And Will Smith as Killer Croc? *sigh* lol

[Stargate21]

So thrilled to see so many folks agree with my Hendricks as Ivy idea. :D
I really think she could knock that one right out of the park.

I agree that Hendricks needs to play as Poison Ivy in the next Batman film.

[Caped Crusader 13]

Jus wonderin but has the character list for the movie been revealed yet?

[Joe Chill]

Jus wonderin but has the character list for the movie been revealed yet?

No, we're just speculating.

[ChristianBaleBatman]

Christina Hendricks doesn't look thick.

But, she's got my vote.

Christian Bale, Michael Caine, Gary Oldman...and then go from there.

I'd enjoy the Riddler brought to Nolanverse, as well as Mr. Freeze. Catwoman and Talia would be great too.

[DrDoom]

This really doesn't add much to the thread but....

http://arcona.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/564.jpg




By the way that's not real.

[ChristianBaleBatman]

The Riddler would be perfect for a Joker-esque viral marketing.

[JackWinz]

I don't care, as long as I get to see Bane, or the return of mad love (Joker n' Harley) I'll be happy! (preferabley bane)

[CodeBlack]

Actually, casting US Presidents as villains (not necessarily Batman) sounds pretty fun.

Eisenhower or Truman definitely look the part for Lex Luthor

McKinley or Woodrow Wilson as William Stryker.

[ChristianBaleBatman]

I think we'll have to wait a long while before Mad Love gets done on the bigscreen. A decade, at the least, I think.

[DrDoom]

Personally I'd rather not see Bane.

[Ryanodamonkey]

anyone else think Eva Green for Poison Ivy?

I liked the Idea of Mr Freeze - Christopher Lee - voice in suit
????????????? - inside suit

(hugo weaving is Australian by the way guys :p)

I dont mind who they put as the baddy in B3 I just hope its someone who will test Batman again maybe not so much mentally like Riddler but a different way. This just screams someone more than Human in the next one like Mr Freeze or Poison Ivy. I would like Penguin though as the Mob boss and a Riddler cameo sort of like B:AA.

Mr Freeze is a deep character that needs the justice delt to him!

[warvibe24]

Agreed. Even when she tries to sound sexy in TF2, she just sounds annoying.

Very true, Her in TF1 was how her acting should have stayed

[omerdav]

ok. i am going to fully write my entire batman 3 theory, so prepare for a long but cool post:
-NO JOKER. NO TWO FACE. if that'll happen, i will sue chris nolan.
-the bank manager will return IMO. what bigger clue than saying "if it doesn't kill you it simply makes you stranger" and shoving a smoke grenade (THAT DOESN'T KILL YOU) in his mouth. about his role, idk. this actor,william fichtner,is a fine actor that got crappy roles. it's his time to shine, as riddler or perhaps as a new mob boss.
-kristen bell portrays harley quinn, but not at the comics form. replacing the joker will be EPIC FAIL, so she'll have to be obsessed with the joker, or be in some one-sided relationship with him. her connection to psychology may be one of two things - psychology student or rising psychologist (not stupid at both cases. bubbly but not stupid) at gotham (non arkham psychologist). we'll see the movie's opening set when reports on the joker crimes started to appear. harlene will start to collect data and track media coverage. her obsession takes shape as she devotes a whole room in her appartment for joker information. after TDK events, bruce will start sessions at her clinique to talk about what happened to him in the last few months (without revealing his alter ego). as all of this happens, harlene starts planning a massive break-in to arkham that will include the release of prisoners and the joker, specifically. she starts sewing the costume, stealing blueprints of arkham etc. the climax of the movie shows her carving a smile to herself as a vow for the break-in to happen. afterwards, she gathers former joker hencmen and robbs a bank, while fox (freeman) is there. fox notifies bruce by a text message. harlene notices and kills fox. bruce appears as batman at the bank. him and harley quinn have little fight. batman is knocked out by harley and her henchmen as they flee the scene and drive towards arkham. {insert big explosive fight in arkham here} harley is defeated and iocked in the asylum.
-possible appearence of poison ivy (hendricks) as harley's BFF and part-time ecco terrorist.
-of course, the main theme of the movie is batman's prosecution and redemption.

[Joe Chill]

Eva Green does have somewhat of the Poison Ivy look, but I can't imagine her with red hair.

As for Kristen Bell---I don't know. She definitely LOOKS like she could pull off a good Harley, but I don't know about personality.

Your movie synopsis sounds pretty good, though. Except for Lucius dying.

[omerdav]

Eva Green does have somewhat of the Poison Ivy look, but I can't imagine her with red hair.

As for Kristen Bell---I don't know. She definitely LOOKS like she could pull off a good Harley, but I don't know about personality.

Your movie synopsis sounds pretty good, though. Except for Lucius dying.


Kristen Bell would nail it. i think she has that bubbly-mentally-insane personality.
what's wrong with lucius dying? what role will he fill in the next batman movies?
as with TDK, a short scene of the new batmobile and some other gadgetry is enough, then chris can say that "batman has achieved gadget perfection" and end it all with one shot.

[Joe Chill]

Kristen Bell would nail it. i think she has that bubbly-mentally-insane personality.
what's wrong with lucius dying? what role will he fill in the next batman movies?
as with TDK, a short scene of the new batmobile and some other gadgetry is enough, then chris can say that "batman has achieved gadget perfection" and end it all with one shot.

It's not him dying so much that bothers me, it's more like the way you say he's killed. Plus, he is kinda the "man behind the scenes" at WayneTech, so I guess he really shouldn't die.

Maybe just have something bad happen to him that makes him have to work from home or something? Maybe temporarily have him in a wheelchair at the end of the film or in a hospital bed at ICU. I don't know. lol

[omerdav]

It's not him dying so much that bothers me, it's more like the way you say he's killed. Plus, he is kinda the "man behind the scenes" at WayneTech, so I guess he really shouldn't die.

Maybe just have something bad happen to him that makes him have to work from home or something? Maybe temporarily have him in a wheelchair at the end of the film or in a hospital bed at ICU. I don't know. lol

you really got me thinking...... What if Isely is working at Wayne Enterprises? as the CEO of Wayne Enterprises, Ivy thinks he's responsible for environmental destruction. as such, she decides to poison him. last-minute rescue for him as he'll be rescued by batman.

BUT WAIT! THERE'S MORE! What if Harley (after fully becoming Harley Quinn, before the bank robbery) convinces Ivy to join her for the Arkham break-in? that'll be EPIC.

[warvibe24]

Jared Padalecki as Nightwing

[Adache]

I think Brittany Murphy would be good as Harley, Phillip Seymour Hoffman as The Penguin, Brock Lesnar as Bane, David Tennant as The Riddler.

[batfan08]

Johnny Depp as poison Ivy.(See Alice in Wonderland):rasp:

[Joe Chill]

you really got me thinking...... What if Isely is working at Wayne Enterprises? as the CEO of Wayne Enterprises, Ivy thinks he's responsible for environmental destruction. as such, she decides to poison him. last-minute rescue for him as he'll be rescued by batman.

BUT WAIT! THERE'S MORE! What if Harley (after fully becoming Harley Quinn, before the bank robbery) convinces Ivy to join her for the Arkham break-in? that'll be EPIC.

Now, that definitely sounds a lot better. Props, my friend.

[Joe Chill]

I think Brittany Murphy would be good as Harley, Phillip Seymour Hoffman as The Penguin, Brock Lesnar as Bane, David Tennant as The Riddler.

Brock Lesnar might work as the "venomed-up" Bane as long as he wore the mask and we didn't see his face and his blonde hair. lol

And if Hoffman is going to pull of the Penguin, he better start gaining weight like Stallone did for Cop Land.

And your choice for Harley...I'm not even going to touch that one.

[warvibe24]

One problem, Brock Lesnar can't act if his life depended on it.

[Matches Malone]

I think I would rather see Snyder do The Dark Knight Returns.

[Joe Chill]

One problem, Brock Lesnar can't act if his life depended on it.

That's just it. All he has to do is beat up crap and walk around like a beast. He doesn't even have to do the talking, they could let someone else do a voice over or something. lol

I agree, though, I mean having ANY athlete play the part will more than likely end up being cheesy. As far as being buff and having the look for Bane, though, Lesnar would probably be a decent choice.

[lukeob94]

catwoman: angelina jolie,charlize theron,jessica alba,jessica biel,

harley: charlize theron, scarlett johansen,cameron diaz

ivy: girl who plays eden on niptuck(i think she's in gossip girls too),christina ricci,eva green,lindsay lohan(well if she gained 25 lbs like in her older movies and become series about acting cuz she gots the look)

bane:javier bardem

scarcrow:cillian murphy(cuz he is the best)

[stoobytoons]

Had an idea for Poison Ivy. Apparently she was right under my nose in terms of DC films and actors previously connected to them: Malin Ackerman

Check it out: http://superherohype.com/nextraimages/malinwatchmen2.jpg

[lukeob94]

my poison ivy story:
has already earned degrees in toxicology and plants and is hired for work at WE. every takes notice of her because she is a hot red head.no one knows how eco nuts she is and her real motives are to destroy WE for whatever reasons(perhaps they have a new flagships in costa rica and had to take down trees) and eventually starts seducing people poisoning them and killing them.she can grow(not like with her mind,more like throwing crazy growing seeds she made in a lab) crazy plants that grow rapidly and can destory stuctures such as building,she can also use many powders or sprays that can cause allergic reactions (like scarecrow) and perhaps use a cross bow thing like in TAS.basically she can start seducing bruce wayne in hopes to kill him,he could fall like really hard for her and have more of a personal deep vendetta against her for trying to destroy his father's company and toying with emotions, and then trying to kill him and destroy his city to create a jungle.this would deepen her past just a vixen and root her in more as real crazy villian.

[Riddling Artist]

Jared Padalecki as Nightwing

there has to be a robin in order for there to be a nightwing. and nolan said robin wont be in his movies (that is if he returns to the 3rd one)

[stoobytoons]

there has to be a robin in order for there to be a nightwing. and nolan said robin wont be in his movies (that is if he returns to the 3rd one)

Which is fine with me. Nolan's directing the beginning of Batman's career. I think if Robin came in, there's a way to do it, but it would need to be done without the slightest bit of "silliness" or it'll get lost on fans REAL quick.

Y'know? I think the next director should put Batman into the world of the 1940's. THAT would be interesting.

[Ryanodamonkey]

I really dont see how Lindsay Lohan could play Poison Ivy she's just doesnt bring across the sadistic nature of Ivy and also I dont really value her as much of a great actress.

I think Malin Ackerman was a good suggestion but I still have to see Watchmen so I dont know how she is as an actress.

I would see Christina Ricci as more of a Harley than Ivy because she can play the proper crazy person much better. :p

Dont agree with eden lord from Nip Tuck

Malin Ackerman and Eva Green top my poll

Any other suggestions for someone who can play a bit of a sadistic/slightly insane role?

[EliteF50]

there has to be a robin in order for there to be a nightwing. and nolan said robin wont be in his movies (that is if he returns to the 3rd one)

Well, if they ever made a Nightwing movie, I also think he should be cast.

[Riddling Artist]

yeah. i nightwing movie would be good... speaking of robins. wasn there a teen titans movie in the works?

[Zombie-Gamer]

yeah. i nightwing movie would be good... speaking of robins. wasn there a teen titans movie in the works?

Yup, there was 2 Teen Titans: The Judas Contract (animated) and a live action 1 but both seem to be on the rocks at the moment :(

[Riddling Artist]

i was on google the other day and saw the movie poster. apparently robins bald. and then there was that wizard magazine article that had their cast for Teen Titans and seth green would be beast boy.

[lukeob94]

I really dont see how Lindsay Lohan could play Poison Ivy she's just doesnt bring across the sadistic nature of Ivy and also I dont really value her as much of a great actress.

I think Malin Ackerman was a good suggestion but I still have to see Watchmen so I dont know how she is as an actress.

I would see Christina Ricci as more of a Harley than Ivy because she can play the proper crazy person much better. :p

Dont agree with eden lord from Nip Tuck

Malin Ackerman and Eva Green top my poll

Any other suggestions for someone who can play a bit of a sadistic/slightly insane role?

what about kate walsh as ivy? she looks kinda old though......
did you like the direction of my ivy plot?

[The Joker 1]

I would like Christian Bale as Batman again because he has made 2 already.

I would like Jim Carry as The Joker or any other actor that can do it.

I would like Johnnny Depp as The Riddler

Dustin Seymore Hoffman as The Penguin.

And the same cast as the other last ones

[Riddling Artist]

jim carry as the joker... hmm... im sure it could happen but not in the nolanverse

[lukeob94]

The idea of Christina Hendricks as Poison Ivy has grown on me a lot. I don't care if she is a little thick. She is the sexiest red head on TV.

http://www.411mania.com/siteimages/curvyhendricks2_26027.jpg

i think poison ivy looks good thicker(and shorter) i mean like the batman tas (yeah i know it's creepy to like a cartoon)ivy was very much so and i'd rather have that than tall and lanky like uma thurman.(BTW i'm a big ivy ,as well as scarecrow fan)

[Joe Chill]

I would like...Dustin Seymore Hoffman as The Penguin.

Who? ;)

[omerdav]

my poison ivy story:
has already earned degrees in toxicology and plants and is hired for work at WE. every takes notice of her because she is a hot red head.no one knows how eco nuts she is and her real motives are to destroy WE for whatever reasons(perhaps they have a new flagships in costa rica and had to take down trees) and eventually starts seducing people poisoning them and killing them.she can grow(not like with her mind,more like throwing crazy growing seeds she made in a lab) crazy plants that grow rapidly and can destory stuctures such as building,she can also use many powders or sprays that can cause allergic reactions (like scarecrow) and perhaps use a cross bow thing like in TAS.basically she can start seducing bruce wayne in hopes to kill him,he could fall like really hard for her and have more of a personal deep vendetta against her for trying to destroy his father's company and toying with emotions, and then trying to kill him and destroy his city to create a jungle.this would deepen her past just a vixen and root her in more as real crazy villian.

the beginning was k, but when you mentioned the things with the powders and plants and all,
you took us all back to the dark age of 1997.

[lukeob94]

the beginning was k, but when you mentioned the things with the powders and plants and all,
you took us all back to the dark age of 1997.

well i tried to make it sound more realistic like less mind control and more of she actually grew the plants.

i still think the powder thing isn't as horrible as "grow for mommy my babies" -batman and robin or "my vines have a crush on you"

actually those aren't that bad even just the stupid puns

i mean like she throws it and it causes reaction :burning,paralysis,sleep idk

but still i'd like her to be more than a crazy plant vixen
like show how deeply she cares about plants
and how she can actually seduce bruce wayne and try to kill him
so it's more personal,like she's not just messing with batman: she's killing his friends and people of gotham,trying to destroy his father's buisness, and the player BW is actually getting played for once.

[Batman_Sauce024]

http://i26.tinypic.com/2jb7c6g.jpg http://i31.tinypic.com/244zblg.jpg

Jack Black has the penguin lmfao.

[Joe Chill]

http://i26.tinypic.com/2jb7c6g.jpg http://i31.tinypic.com/244zblg.jpg

Jack Black has the penguin lmfao.

Oh, God, no. Please, no!

That would be one of the worst castings of all time. Put him as the Penguin and Carrey back as the Riddler and you have Batman hell---Schumaker would be directing, of course. :rolleyes:

[omerdav]

well i tried to make it sound more realistic like less mind control and more of she actually grew the plants.

i still think the powder thing isn't as horrible as "grow for mommy my babies" -batman and robin or "my vines have a crush on you"

actually those aren't that bad even just the stupid puns

i mean like she throws it and it causes reaction :burning,paralysis,sleep idk

but still i'd like her to be more than a crazy plant vixen
like show how deeply she cares about plants
and how she can actually seduce bruce wayne and try to kill him
so it's more personal,like she's not just messing with batman: she's killing his friends and people of gotham,trying to destroy his father's buisness, and the player BW is actually getting played for once.

Nolan wants a realistic bat-universe. are there any plants that destroy buildings? powder that causes sleep/paralysis/whatever? no.
if ivy will ever be in those films, the crazy-seductress-plant-vixen might work sans magical powders (see what i did there?) and murderous plants.
the MO of seducing and poisoning her victims is enough.

[Joe Chill]

Nolan wants a realistic bat-universe. are there any plants that destroy buildings? powder that causes sleep/paralysis/whatever? no.
if ivy will ever be in those films, the crazy-seductress-plant-vixen might work sans magical powders (see what i did there?) and murderous plants.
the MO of seducing and poisoning her victims is enough.

Agreed.

[DrCLos]

For those who were wondering, Malin Ackerman is a bad actress. She was the weakest in Watchmen. She is nice to look at but Christina Hendricks is both a good actress and hotter than Ackerman IMO.

http://www.411mania.com/siteimages/curvyhendricks1_26026.jpg

[stoobytoons]

For those who were wondering, Malin Ackerman is a bad actress. She was the weakest in Watchmen. She is nice to look at but Christina Hendricks is both a good actress and hotter than Ackerman IMO.

http://www.411mania.com/siteimages/curvyhendricks1_26026.jpg

What movies has she been in again?

[DrCLos]

What movies has she been in again?

Here's her resume off IMDB (http://www.411mania.com/siteimages/curvyhendricks1_26026.jpg)
Knock yourself out.

[The New Blueguy]

http://www.nerve.com/CS/blogs/scanner/2008/04/01-07/johnny_depp1_300_400.jpg OR http://dancestothebeetofherowndrum.files.wordpress.com/2008/10/davidtennantbw_preview.jpg

Riddler: Johnny Depp or David Tenant -- Leaning more towards Tenant because Depp seems to rehash old roles to me, I really want to think of Riddler as unique. I don't to see Willy Wonka, The Mad Hatter or Jack Sparrow in my Riddler at all.

Catwoman: I'm not sure... Yes, I know Angelina Jolie blah.... Look as long as Alba stays away I'm fine with whoever.

http://s.chakpak.com/se_images/118272_-1_564_none/angelina-jolie-wallpaper.jpg

Poison Ivy: Angelina Jolie ... as long as they make her as seuctive and deadly as she is... Less camp. Sorry Uma Thurman

http://i134.photobucket.com/albums/q117/kcfmc/like%20to%20meet/Danny_Trejo_El_Mexicanismo.jpg

Bane: Danny Trejo ... If you've ever seen him in anything, you know why. Trust me, he can do a ruthless and intectually sound Bane. Just hit the gym a little.

http://blogu.lu/dreia/files/2009/03/anthony_hopkins.jpg OR http://www.hbo.com/films/mrsharris/img/castandcrew/506X316_ben.jpgHugo Strange: Anthony Hopkins or Ben Kingsley

http://www.theage.com.au/ffximage/2006/06/01/truman_narrowweb__300x460,0.jpg OR http://www.enfrentearte.com/hotel-ronda/uploaded_images/BobHoskins-790655.jpg

Penguin: Philip Seymour Hoffman or Bob Hoskins

This would be ideal cast.

[omerdav]

blueguy, if that happens we're doomed. no, really.

[lukeob94]

Nolan wants a realistic bat-universe. are there any plants that destroy buildings? powder that causes sleep/paralysis/whatever? no.
if ivy will ever be in those films, the crazy-seductress-plant-vixen might work sans magical powders (see what i did there?) and murderous plants.
the MO of seducing and poisoning her victims is enough.

umm plants do destroy buildings (watch life after people)
but i guess your right
but do you understand the direction i mean<like as a more serious character?

[Mr_Scarecrow_Goes_To_Town]

Batman - Christian Bale. Hopefully the idiot sound guy from the Dark Knight doesn't make Batman sound like a blender full of gravel again.

The Riddler - Hugo Weaving or David Tennant. Personally I lean more towards Hugo Weaving as I have more experience watching Hugo Weaving act.

"Riddle me this, Mr. Anderson." :P

The Scarecrow - Cillian Murphy obviously. Hopefully they give him a bigger role that the last two films, but that may be coming from me because I'm a huge fan.

When Nolan stops making Batman films, I'd like to see Tim Curry as everyone's favorite homicidal clown. He sold me on the fact that he can play clowns in IT, but I'd like to see how far he can take the role. He is a brilliant actor after all...

There's my two cents

[Batman_Sauce024]

http://i29.tinypic.com/zwysjo.jpg http://i31.tinypic.com/2zqx3y0.jpg

Edward Norton as Mr Freeze! I can really see him being Mr Freeze. Hes a great actor and personally one of my favorites. He can sell and be a great Mr Freeze. Way better than Arnold.

[imbatman]

i always thought David Bowie would make a good scary Scarecrow http://i15.photobucket.com/albums/a361/maxkersey/David_Bowie.jpg

[stoobytoons]

Here's her resume off IMDB (http://www.411mania.com/siteimages/curvyhendricks1_26026.jpg)
Knock yourself out.

Sorry, boy-o. You gave me a link to a .jpg.
I frequent IMDB though. I would've expected at least one or two examples. Meh.. maybe it's not worth it.

[DrCLos]

Sorry, boy-o. You gave me a link to a .jpg.
I frequent IMDB though. I would've expected at least one or two examples. Meh.. maybe it's not worth it.

Doh! Sorry about that. Here you go for real. (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0376716/)

[stoobytoons]

Well, I didn't see anything that I recognized her from. I watched a clip from Mad Men. She's got a nice face, but he's a bit... larger.. than you might expect Ivy to be.

[Brickyman]

Even though i'd hate to see bane, i think Dalip singh would be the best choice. I mean, look at him! He IS bane!!

http://www.gerweck.net/dalipsingh.jpg

And, for Black Mask (My favourite batman villain aside the joker) I reckon daniel craig could do the part well.

http://imstars.aufeminin.com/stars/fan/daniel-craig/daniel-craig-20061124-182061.jpg

[The New Blueguy]

blueguy, if that happens we're doomed. no, really.

Why exactly do you think that? All of those actors are of great quality. Yes, you have your opinion, and I'd actually like to hear it in more than one sentence why you think so.

[omerdav]

Why exactly do you think that? All of those actors are of great quality. Yes, you have your opinion, and I'd actually like to hear it in more than one sentence why you think so.

it was actually 2 sentences :D
but seriously:
about the riddler part, ok, i have no complaints and i think both of them, especially Tennant, will pull off an amazing riddler (do bear in mind the bank manager as riddler option)
about Catwoman part: Alba sort of has the looks, but as far as acting ability goes, she has nothing. that's what we need with Nolan. Jolie might be a bit old for this and it's a cliche casting, and the fact that i (perhaps it's just me) don't trust her acting ability.
Poison Ivy: again, no acting ability, doesn't look liker her...
about Bane: i have 2 words for you - Spy Kids.
Strange: o...k.... Kingsley might work. hopkins.... just doesn't have the looks for it.
Penguin: (apart from the fact that nolan stated that there will not be penguin) hoffman might have the skills for it.

[Joe Chill]

Just thought I'd bump this thread in order to keep all the similar topics together.

[Elpy]

As The Penguin: Philip Seymour-Hoffman
As The Riddler: Johnny Depp
As Catwoman: Angelina Jolie

[Joe Chill]

As The Penguin: Philip Seymour-Hoffman
As The Riddler: Johnny Depp
As Catwoman: Angelina Jolie

Why do you say that? What makes them the "ideal" casting for each role?

Just curious.

[Elpy]

Hoffman was excellent in Capote, where he played a small, depressed man with a troubled childhood. This fits the bill for Penguin almost perfectly. Besides, anything can beat DeVito :P.

Depp would actually be a good Joker, but it's too late. I judge this off his performance in Sweeney Todd. The Riddler's the next best thing.

Catwoman would need a sexy and sassy actress. I was thinking Megan Fox, but she's not that great an actor. (Still, Megan Fox in spandex, *drools*)

[NoMoarDedCawpz]

I know all the following villains wont be in it...but these are my choices for each possible villain:
David Wenham as Killer Moth
Christina Ricci as Harley Quinn
Sienna Miller as Catwoman
Zachary Quinto as The Riddler

[Elpy]

Oh, I almost forgot.

New voice for Batman.

[Unstoppable]

No Depp for Joker as I wouldn't want him to die like Ledger heh jk. Maybe if he want to if not Riddler is fine.

[Wesker89]

why the hell would you want cher ewwww

[The New Blueguy]

it was actually 2 sentences :D
but seriously:
about the riddler part, ok, i have no complaints and i think both of them, especially Tennant, will pull off an amazing riddler (do bear in mind the bank manager as riddler option)
about Catwoman part: Alba sort of has the looks, but as far as acting ability goes, she has nothing. that's what we need with Nolan. Jolie might be a bit old for this and it's a cliche casting, and the fact that i (perhaps it's just me) don't trust her acting ability.
Poison Ivy: again, no acting ability, doesn't look liker her...
about Bane: i have 2 words for you - Spy Kids.
Strange: o...k.... Kingsley might work. hopkins.... just doesn't have the looks for it.
Penguin: (apart from the fact that nolan stated that there will not be penguin) hoffman might have the skills for it.

I never suggested anyone as Catwoman.. I don't know who I'd ahve in mind so I left it open with everyone's pick for Jolie but I think it'd be too obvious. I picked Jolie for Poison Ivy actually because from what I've seen of her in the media (interviews and noting her charity work) I feel like Poison Ivy if played more like the TAS version would simply be an extension of her real life personality turned up to 11.

Kingsley we agree on... Hopkins I believe is a great actor, regardless of having the look or not. I understand it just so happens that Kingsley is a dead ringer for the comics version and is a great actor, but even if they went with Hopkins, I think he'd quickly make us not care what the character looked like.

Really Hoffman's a great choice and all but even though Nolan said no to Penguin, I'd faster see Bob Hoskins in that role.

Never seen Spy Kids 1 or 2... But I know Danny is a capable actor when not given crap tp work with, whether script or director.

I still see Tennant more than Depp for Riddler. I just think Depp's too poster boy. The movie would sell yeah, but I just think his natural persona would kill the subtley of the character as portrayed in TAS. Why am I going off TAS for my analysis? Because it really was the perfection of just about all the characters mentioned here. I've erased Jim Carrey from my mind as I feel that the Schumacher films should never be spoken of by anyone ever again.

[Clown Prince Of Crime]

Even though i'd hate to see bane, i think Dalip singh would be the best choice. I mean, look at him! He IS bane!!

http://www.gerweck.net/dalipsingh.jpg

And, for Black Mask (My favourite batman villain aside the joker) I reckon daniel craig could do the part well.

http://imstars.aufeminin.com/stars/fan/daniel-craig/daniel-craig-20061124-182061.jpg


Are you kidding ?

[Kai Rei]

Are you kidding ?

I hope so. He's neither as intelligent or jacked as Bane.

Edit: And can't act.

[Clown Prince Of Crime]

I hope so. He's neither as intelligent or jacked as Bane.

Edit: And can't act.

Both cannot act.

Craig would just be pouting all film.

[Elpy]

Megan Fox is rumoured to be the next Catwoman, just as I predicted.

[Clown Prince Of Crime]

Megan Fox is rumoured to be the next Catwoman, just as I predicted.

Exactly. Rumoured.

[Kai Rei]

Megan Fox is rumoured to be the next Catwoman, just as I predicted.

She'd be a bad Catwoman IMO. I don't think she can act very well either, she's just ass and breasts bouncing around in the heat of battle. :D


Kate Beckinsale is someone I consider to be a good choice for Catwoman, but she'd need alomost a full-face mask in order to look more like "Catwoman" and less like "huge hollywood star".

[Elpy]

I'd say Angelina Jolie. They're almost identical and Fox isn't a brilliant actor. However, Warner Bros. have said she's not playing the role. Though I'd like to see her in tight leather, I'd probably rather save my pleasure for later and enjoy the movie with a better actress.

[Kai Rei]

I'd say Angelina Jolie. They're almost identical and Fox isn't a brilliant actor. However, Warner Bros. have said she's not playing the role. Though I'd like to see her in tight leather, I'd probably rather save my pleasure for later and enjoy the movie with a better actress.

Angelina would be another great Catwoman. Nice choice.

[Brickyman]

No... I'm very serious actually... Well, about black mask anyway. He is a very good actor, and I reckon he could pull it off well.

[Huey]

First, some of these castings are just awful. Daniel Craig as Black Mask? Angelina Jolie? Mr. Reese as Riddler? Pfffft. Second, most Batman characters simply would not work in Nolan's vision of Batman. That means, no Mr. Freeze, Killer Croc, Clay-Face, Man-Bat, Mad Hatter or others.

I don't think Nolan would go with a full fledged Catwoman. I can see him including Selina Kyle and hint at her Catwoman persona by having something important Mob-wise stolen towards the end, but never actually seeing Catwoman in the film. Kate Beckinsale or Sienna Miller as Selina please, especially with short hair. To a point, female actresses are garbage for deep roles, so the actress doesn't really matter, as long as she can act better then Holmes and Maggie *Shudders* and are attractive. They are only playing Selina Kyle, not Catwoman after all.

http://img.listal.com/image/425754/300-kate-beckinsale.jpg http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/77/460124-catwoman_adam_hughes11_super.jpg http://www.jessicastyle.com/userpix/23387_SiennaMiller17_e_b531446b815d841fa57ff7ac295 59923_1.jpg

I have been saying since Batman Begins came out for Black Mask, more importantly, Willem Dafoe as Black Mask in "Gotham". I think his roles in Boondock Saints, Once upon a time in Mexico, Shadow of the Vampire, and Spider-Man give his the credits to warrant the role. Black Mask is crazy, and Dafoe can play crazy. 2nd Choice would be Hugo Weaving. I'd say have Black Mask bankrupt his parents company and bought by Wayne Ent., driving him to kill his parents, his hatred of Wayne Ent. and locked up in Arkham until the breakout in Begins. Since then, he has been creating a fortune and his own mob through blackmail, racketeering, drug and human trafficking amongst other things. Eventually raising to the top after the apparent death of Sal Maroni up till the beginning of the 3rd film, has been sabotaging several Wayne Ent. facilities and mutilating several key Wayne Ent. employees. Also, there is such a dynamic between Black Mask and Catwoman, I would love to see that portrayed on film.

http://www.korrekt.com/07.01.08_CVHS_01/willem_dafoe_0001.jpg http://www.movie-moron.com/wp-content/gallery/batman-3/black_mask_batman_3_villain.jpg http://blog.ugo.com/images/uploads/HugoWeaving.jpg

2nd villain should definitely be Riddler, especially since he was initially supposed to be the main antagonist in TDK. He's the secondary villain because I really don't see Riddler alone holding an entire movie or audience by himself. I like the Private eye job he's been given since the end of Hush arc, and It's really the only way I can see him being portrayed in the film without being compared to the Joker. I mean, even in the comics before his reform he was refered to several times as,"...a poor man's Joker." I'd want Riddler either as a real genius intellect Profiler transferred to Gotham to help bring in the bat (maybe from Metropolis?) or as a fellow escapee of Arkham and a double agent, hired by Black Mask to work with the police to track down Batman and find out who he is. Either way they are essentially attacking Bruce from all fronts.

And for this role, it's between Crispin Glover and Daniel Day-Lewis. Like Dafoe, Glover can play crazy and creepy, with roles as Willard, the Crazy Man in Charlie's Angels and the Orkly Kid. When it comes to Daniel Day-Lewis, he is just wonderful, and plays over the top, eccentric characters. He'd be great to brin gthe Egotistical Riddler to life.

http://nuevocineespanol.files.wordpress.com/2008/11/crispin-glover-suited1.jpg http://thefaust.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/riddler.jpg http://crfranke.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/daniel-day-lewis_l.jpg

Now for additional thoughts:

I'd like them to show how out of control Gotham is with other villains running around. Have Gotham surrounded by "freaks" to go with what was previously stated throughout TDK and the Long Halloween, that,"...The freaks are taking over. That's the future of this city, not the mob, not the old way.", Phillip Seymour Hoffman as Penguin, but only in a bit part. He manages a front for Black Mask in his racketeering gig with his night club, the Iceberg Lounge. I'd love to see Bane as Black Mask's enforcer in a mexican wrestling mask, but the Venom angle wouldn't really work in Nolan's world. He could possibly make Bane already huge(but reasonable) and Venom a berserker drug that makes you go insane with rage rather than a steroid that rips you out and grow to an unbelievable size in seconds. Done in the right way, Bane can be scary as ****. References to Pamela Isley, The Ventriloquist, and Victor Fries would be greatly appreciated too.

[The_Clown_Prince_Of_Crime]

Ok,I'm not a big fan of A-list names like Jolie & Depp,as talented as they are,I think Nolan's vision is better suited by actors on the rise or established on the edge of greatness.Here are the people I would like to see play characters:
Michael Clarke Duncan as Killer Croc
Juliette Lewis as Harley Quinn (I CANNOT see anyone else but her play Harley,hoping she could tap into that Natural Born Killers psyche to bring Harley to life)
Penguin-Phillip Seymour Hoffman (I don't need to justify my reasons here,the man is ust incredible)
Riddler-If we're going on the classic version of Edward Nigma,none other than Crispin Glover.
If we're going to go for a younger version like the one drawn up by Lee Bermejo in
Joker then I would like to see Joseph Gordon Levitt in the role,I urge anyone who
hasn't seen Brick to watch it and that will tell you all you need to know
Poison Ivy-if we're going young-ish,then Amy Adams but I would love nothing more than to
see Marcia Gay Harden in the role,such a fantastic actress,I reckon she could
really pull it off,go watch The Mist or Damages S2
Catwoman-Emily Blunt,looks good with the talent to match
Victor Zsasz-Ben Foster,for a guy that started out in romantic comedies,he's come into
his own lately,check out Alpha Dog,30 Days Of Night & 3.10 to Yuma as
well as the upcoming Pandorum
Hush-Jeremy Renner,not a very well known name but is one of my favourite actors, check
The Hurt Locker to see what I mean, carries an understated intensity to the
performance & really should be up for best actor at next years oscars

[Joe Chill]

Glad to see one of my favorite threads is getting revived, again.

[EliteF50]

Glad to see one of my favorite threads is getting revived, again.

Glad my thread is someone's favorite. :D

[Black-Xero]

it doesnt matter as long as it's someone who can act and do the role right.just no more bale for batman...

was a 3rd even confirmed? i knew they would make another but never never knew they announced it.

[nanotech1]

Dunno 'bout you guys, but i'm totally seeing Jackie Earle Haley as The Great White Shark!

http://6.media.tumblr.com/KwnXc0Cyspokju7leODTsMxIo1_400.jpg

http://www.comicbookreligion.com/img/g/Great_White_Shark.jpg

EDIT: THIS LOOKS SO AWESOME!!:

http://jayfingers.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/batman_3_poster___harley_quinn_by_joshwmc.jpg

It's David Tennant as The Riddler, Kristen Bell as Harley Quinn and Marion Cottilard as Catwoman (I think).

[Joe Chill]

^ Yeah, I've seen those.

I dunno. Am I the only one that doesn't like that look for Harley?

[nanotech1]

^ Yeah, I've seen those.

I dunno. Am I the only one that doesn't like that look for Harley?

Yeh those are bad pics, i just got them quickly. The Great White Shark that he'd be good for is the one in his Arkham Asylum Bio, the facial features resemble Jackie Earle more. I think Harley looks good, the only thing is the painted smile, it's too Joker-like.

[EliteF50]

http://jayfingers.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/batman_3_poster___harley_quinn_by_joshwmc.jpg

It's David Tennant as The Riddler, Kristen Bell as Harley Quinn and Marion Cottilard as Catwoman (I think).

Eww...

[Joe Chill]

Eww...

:thumb:

[EliteF50]

Kristen Bell would make a good Harley:

Warning: If you're not over 14, don't click on this image

http://www.bryceforvice.com/storage/kristen-bell10220601.jpg

[Joe Chill]

Kristen Bell would make a good Harley:

Warning: If you're not over 14, don't click on this image

http://www.bryceforvice.com/storage/kristen-bell10220601.jpg

Wow, I agree!

And I'm glad I'm 22!

[Kai Rei]

Wow, I agree!

And I'm glad I'm 22!

lol...

She's a beaut alright. ;)

[Dutchman345]

sorry. i was kinda bored. eminem would be interesting but the other ones i was kiddin. but the way i wanted the characters to be portrayed are what i would want. (kristen bell sucked in Max Payne and the only move i liked with vin diesel was pitch black)

I want Eminem shot dead.

I don't agree with all the people choosing guys like Diesel, Schwazeneggar and Johnson for Mr. Freeze, cause he's originally a skinny 40yr old scientist whose suit makes him look bulky.

And I don't know how Kristen Bell could suck in Max Payne, she wasn't even in it.

Depp as Riddler!!!!

[Dutchman345]

This would be my dream casting for any villains in the future Nolanverse films:

Aaron Eckhart - Two-Face (I would love to see more Two-Face and hope that a storyline involving his funeral being faked for the public to hide what has really happened to Harvey Dent. Besides, how can Batman be removed of charges for the murders commited by Dent. Only a reappearance by Two-Face could clear the Dark Knight's good name)

Cillian Murphy - Scarecrow (What can I say, I love the Scarecrow and I love Cillian Murphy's acting). Trivia note: Nolan was so fascinated by Murphy's eyes he repeatedly found reasons for Murphy to take his glasses off in the first film)

Johnny Depp - The Riddler (I wouldn't pick him for the Mad Hatter considering he's already doing Tim Burton's Alice In Wonderland)

Kristen Bell - Harley Quinn (I just think she suits it she's got the right look in the facial features, I could seriously imagine her with her hair up in tails and a harlequin outfit)

Patrick Stewart - Mr. Freeze (Not simply because he already has a bald head =P but Patrick has a great voice and I think if the story of his wife is done right Patrick could deliver the kind of Freeze that is not only a great villain but also a character that we could sympathise for)

Killer Croc - Steve Blum (Blum's voice for Croc in Batman Arkham Asylum was top notch and if Croc were done (doubtful in Nolanverse which has to be realistic, one of the reasons Nolan stated he would never use the Penguin as he thought him to be too unrealistic) Croc would have to be CGI. Excessive makeup wouldn't look too good, unless they could do it right.

Penguin - Phillip Seymour Hoffman (I've heard his name come up alot for this and I gotta admit he would be good, but his height would be an issue for me, and in my opinion no one could ever beat Danny Devito's Penguin)

Catwoman - Rachel Weisz (one of my favourite actresses, I think she could make a very seductive and very beautiful Catwoman)

Poison Ivy - Rachel McAdams (another Rachel, and I think she would make a far better Poison Ivy than what we saw in Schumacher's disaster. Schumacher should never have taken away Tim Burton's reigns. But have Rachel with red hair and have her half-human half-plant appearance and I think McAdams would be a great candidate)

[JackWinz]

Patrick Stewart - Mr. Freeze (Not simply because he already has a bald head =P but Patrick has a great voice and I think if the story of his wife is done right Patrick could deliver the kind of Freeze that is not only a great villain but also a character that we could sympathise for)

OMG! everytime I hear mention of Freeze in batman 3 I cringe, but that's actaully a really good idea!

[Brako]

I would love to see Daniel Day Lewis as one of the Batman villains. That wicked smile and amazing acting he does could be perfect for a bunch of characters...but I seriously doubt we would see this happen.

[Mr_Scarecrow_Goes_To_Town]

I would love to see Daniel Day Lewis as one of the Batman villains. That wicked smile and amazing acting he does could be perfect for a bunch of characters...but I seriously doubt we would see this happen.

I'd love to see Daniel Day Lewis as Firefly, my other favorite villain. :D

[batfan08]

Patrick Wilson as Killer Moth :p

[The Joker 1]

You know, Michael C. Hall impressed me on The Gamer movie, at the end. He could make a great Joker guys! Great Joker. I didn't like the movie not even for a moment, but Michael C. Hall was great at the end! Specially when he danced! LOL

[batfan08]

You know, Michael C. Hall impressed me on The Gamer movie, at the end. He could make a great Joker guys! Great Joker. I didn't like the movie not even for a moment, but Michael C. Hall was great at the end! Specially when he danced! LOL

Michael C. Hall is a fantastic actor,and if you haven't seen Dexter,you should check it out.I personally think he'd make a good Thomas Elliot/Hush,what do you guys think?

http://thinkculture.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/michael-c-hall-sag.jpg

http://healingtouch.scvs4hire.com/images/blog/articles/top10batman/batmanH2.png

[SolidSnake_123]

Kristen Bell would make a good Harley:

Warning: If you're not over 14, don't click on this image

http://www.bryceforvice.com/storage/kristen-bell10220601.jpg

Hehe.. I'm 14 exactly lol.

[TitanJoker]

If they DO put the Joker in for a short part of it then Johnny Depp

The Riddler: Jim Carrey would be my only real decision (Or Johnny) I guess, but Jim did say after "23" he'd like to do darker roles, if he can go a bit darker on the Riddler that would be great!

[butterskenny]

Jim already did the riddler..

[lukeob94]

for poison ivy(the only villain i really wnat cuz she a fav right after joker)

so for her

1) kate walsh(really she just screams dr.pamela lillian isley to me,but maybe too old)
http://i114.photobucket.com/albums/n270/taylinsicons/0ther%20stuff/Possible%20Characters/068.jpg
2) cristinna (crazy,sexy,and could do more of the short petitie ivy like in tas)
http://i103.photobucket.com/albums/m156/xxbilliebilliexx/cr01.jpg
3)anna lynne mccord(plays the vixen role well,but maybe too young)
http://i602.photobucket.com/albums/tt107/RDA123/AnnaLynne2-3.jpg
4)kate winslet(she might be too old though)
http://i1021.photobucket.com/albums/af339/beautyk/kate_winslet.jpg
5)cristina hendricks(yes! but a lil too tall)
http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e1/cegikma/life.jpg

also for bane javier bardem

based off of no country for old men:
he's crazy
intelligent
supper stronng
latin(yes bane is south american,can't believe how many people never realized that)
and a good actor

catwoman:
angie (sorry but i think she could do it)
the actress from the mummy(someone mentioned her)
charlize theron

harley:
brittany murphy

[batfan08]

Here are my updated picks:
Michael C. Hall-Dr.Thomas Elliot/Hush

http://thinkculture.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/michael-c-hall-sag.jpg

http://healingtouch.scvs4hire.com/images/blog/articles/top10batman/batmanH2.png

Marion Cotilard-Selina Kyle/Catwoman

http://keyshun.canalblog.com/images/Marion_Cotillard.jpg

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_Rf9S3GkkeyI/SgmFcVI0gyI/AAAAAAAAQXI/GDYARu0xxQ4/s400/alex+ross.+catwoman.+001.jpg

Michael Madsen-Det.Harvey Bullock

http://www.boysrepublic.org/img/photo/Michael_Madsen.jpg

http://www.comicbookmovie.com/images/users/uploads/9792/250px-GothamCentralCv22.jpg

James Gandolfini-Oswald Cobblepot/The Penguin

http://celebrity-pics.movieeye.com/celebrity_pictures/James_Gandolfini_104580.jpg

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/e/e3/DetectiveComics824b.jpg/250px-DetectiveComics824b.jpg

[batfan08]

Johnny Depp-Edward Nashton(Edward Nigma)/The Riddler

http://www.thehollywoodnews.com/artman2/uploads/1/johnny_depp_3.jpg

http://thefaust.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/riddler.jpg

Christian Bale-Bruce Wayne/Batman

http://www.ambrosia.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2008/07/filme-the-dark-knight-christian-bale-bruce-wayne.jpg

http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/j/msnbc/Components/Photo/_new/g-080718-cvr-batman.hmedium.jpg

Gary Oldman-Com.James Gordon

http://www.filmgrenade.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/05/interview-with-gary-oldman-about-the-dark-knight.jpg

Michael Caine-Alfred Pennyworth

http://www.filmdope.com/Gallery/ActorsC/2517-27939.gif

Morgan Freeman-Lucius Fox

http://us.movies1.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/movie_pix/warner_brothers/batman_begins/morgan_freeman/batman.jpg

Aaron Eckhart-Harvey Dent/Two-Face

http://www.tutorialsbeware.com/tutorial/jonahhex/2face.jpg

[Mistress of Fear]

Cillian Murphy - Scarecrow (What can I say, I love the Scarecrow and I love Cillian Murphy's acting). Trivia note: Nolan was so fascinated by Murphy's eyes he repeatedly found reasons for Murphy to take his glasses off in the first film)


If he is in the movie again I want him an a actual scarecrow costume not just a burlap sack over his head as he sports a business suit. Something like this (http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w256/BiteyTheVampire/scarecrow3.jpg) or this (http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w256/BiteyTheVampire/945scarecrow.png).
Other then that I liked him (even though he doesn't look like what I think the Scarecrow should look like he can act well in my opinion).
As for some of the other villains so far a lot of the suggestions already here I agree with...but it's 3 in the morning here and I'm blanking out on names. >_>

[fatal shadow]

Funny, those are my two favorite Scarecrow designs.
I don't think Sale's 'crow could work in the Nolan films, design-wise, being more stylized. Especially given the (insanely long) witch hat. And if they'd replace the hat, it'd look too much like Dr. Syn in his scarecrow outfit.

Eaglesham's Scarecrow could work.

Or any design. Just get him in a scarecrow costume! The movies revolve around a guy who dresses like a bat, why can't they have Dr. Crane in his getup?

[redderz93]

Scarlett Johansson as Pamela Isley/Poison Ivy
http://celebrityandworld.files.wordpress.com/2009/06/scarlett-johansson.jpg
http://www.comicbookmovie.com/images/users/uploads/9366/poison-ivy_super.jpg

Aaron Eckhart as Harvey Dent/Two-Face (HE CAN'T BE DEAD!!!!)
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/c/c7/Two-faceEckhart.jpg

Tyler Mane as Bane
http://z.about.com/d/movies/1/0/e/Q/P/saturn07pic84.jpg
http://janeward.files.wordpress.com/2008/07/bane.jpg

Cillian Murphy as Johnathon Crane/Scarecrow
http://www.filmdope.com/Gallery/ActorsM/47141-26622.gif

Scarlett because she's hot AND she can act ;)

Aaron = Best Two-Face ever!!!

Tyler because he's 6ft 9 and has played some badass characters

Cillian because he made me actually like Scarecrow :D

[Mistress of Fear]

Funny, those are my two favorite Scarecrow designs.
I don't think Sale's 'crow could work in the Nolan films, design-wise, being more stylized. Especially given the (insanely long) witch hat. And if they'd replace the hat, it'd look too much like Dr. Syn in his scarecrow outfit.

Eaglesham's Scarecrow could work.

Or any design. Just get him in a scarecrow costume! The movies revolve around a guy who dresses like a bat, why can't they have Dr. Crane in his getup?

Mine too, probably not (looks awesome though) I wouldn't want the witch hat replaced it's one of my favorite ones =) (cause it's insanely long ).His would work but I bet Nolan would like the colors (not dark enough :rolleyes: everything has to be dark with that guy). Doesn't think it would be scary? I don't know but if he is in it again he needs to be in some type of scarecrow costume.

[Mr_Scarecrow_Goes_To_Town]

I tried to post a funny picture, but failed. This doesn't happen usually.

[wikiker]

Lol Rock would be a good Bane...he's playing I read somewhere Black Adam in the Shazam/Captain Marvel Movie, and he's a perfect Ugg boot (http://www.sneakers2world.com/wholesale/UGG-Australia-469_P1.html) fit, I say Riddler - Depp, Angelina Jolie as Catwoman and Ron Pearlman as Clayface...

[zombiee25]

Angelina Jolie would be just plain crap as catwoman. as much as i'd lilke to see a catwoman i think they should leave her out since there isn't really anyone i can think of to play her. but they should have

Timothy Spall - Penguin
and
Matthew Gray Gubler - The Riddler

[zombiee25]

Dunno 'bout you guys, but i'm totally seeing Jackie Earle Haley as The Great White Shark!

http://6.media.tumblr.com/KwnXc0Cyspokju7leODTsMxIo1_400.jpg

http://www.comicbookreligion.com/img/g/Great_White_Shark.jpg

EDIT: THIS LOOKS SO AWESOME!!:

http://jayfingers.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/batman_3_poster___harley_quinn_by_joshwmc.jpg

It's David Tennant as The Riddler, Kristen Bell as Harley Quinn and Marion Cottilard as Catwoman (I think).

makes me wanna crap my own pants. harley better be hot and have a killer bod. and kristen bell is neither

[Paulley]

http://i175.photobucket.com/albums/w123/Paulley55/10846953_profile_mbox_background.jpg

The Clock King (like the one in Timmeverse)... played by John Lithgow

[kalle90]

From the consistency viewpoint source (http://blogs.coventrytelegraph.net/thegeekfiles/2009/01/could-william-fichtner-become.html)
Joshua Harto as The Riddler. He knows Batman's most valuable secret. He's clearly arrogant and has a reason to hate Bat.
William Fichtner as Penguin. There's open room for crime leaders. There's one user comment that supports this too.
I think the Catwoman stuff is really unfounded.

From the pure imagination field, I'm just being boring:
- Johnny Depp as the Riddler. There could be some good scenes bethween Bale and Depp although they just were together in that 1 movie.
- Angelina Jolie as Catwoman. Because she's a cat
- Philip Seymour Hoffman as Penguin. Because he looks like mob leader and he was one in Mission Impossible.

Whoever Nolan chooses I trust him. But I think those 3 are the most urgent ones, the likes of Poison Ivy and Bane don't seem to have any logical reason to exist right after TDK.

[EliteF50]

Olivia Wilde has to play Catwoman.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b5/Olivia_Wilde_by_David_Shankbone.jpg/250px-Olivia_Wilde_by_David_Shankbone.jpg

[Solomon Grundy]

have you guys heard the rumor of miley cyrus auditioning for batgirl.


http://angryape.com/news/miley-cyrus-auditions-for-new-batman-movie


personally kate beckinsale or angelina jolie for catwoman
two-face should come back
hush definetly but i dont know who should play him

[zombiee25]

What movies has she been in again?

does it matter. LOOK at her, i would go see it just to stare at her for 2 hours

[Creature of the Night]

my cast

Thomas Jane Bruce Wayne/Batman (I hate Bale)

Dominic West Joker

Aaron Eckhart Harvey Dent/Two Face

Johnny Depp The Riddler

Kate Beckinsale Selina Kyle/Catwomen

Cillian Murphy The Scarecrow

[lukeob94]

my list(nolan series)

scarecrow:Cillian Murphy
Two Fcae:Arron Eckhart
poison ivy:Christina Hendricks(she is so hot)
Harley:Britanny Murphy
bane:javier bardem
catwoman:omg so many :Racheal Wiez,Catehrin Zeta Jones,or Angelin
(someone please explain to me why angie is not a good choice i mean she is very talented and beautiful?so why she not good catwoman)Charlize theron
r

[Scaretheweans]

Two face wont come back IMO, he was dead, you think Gordon would take the body away and have a memorial service and everything, but secretly he dissappeared, c'mon

Dont need him, his story worked better as standalone in TDK.

David Tenant as Riddler, that guys is awesome in anything he does, best Dr Who ever (Just keep your scottish accent for a bit of fun though)

Someone to play Catwoman, I trust them

Penguin wont be there but if he was Id say Daniel Day lewis, and if he was in it he would be as the new Mob boss, not an insane criminal, which he was never really in the comics.

Yep, Id have scarecrow back with Murphy, but appear mostly with mask and costume rather than as Crane.

That would be it for me

Oh and I dont like Bane, never had, so I would deffo not want to see him in any Nolan movies, I dont think it would work, same with Croc

[suvachi]

I'd like to see Jim Carrey come back as Riddler

[JackWinz]

I'd like to see Jim Carrey come back as Riddler

I'd like to seehim replace Ledger... Srsly..

[The Hylden]

Uh, ew to both possibilities :rasp:

[fatal shadow]

I'd like to seehim replace Ledger... Srsly..

http://img.moronail.net/img/0/2/1302.jpg

[BishopBee]

I will throw in my 2 cents,

Paul Giamatti as Mad Hatter (funny but intense)
Rosario Dawson/Eliza Dushku as Catwomen (as ooze sex and a bit of liveliness)
Daniel Craig as Hush (looking for someone similar to Bale)
Phillip Seamore Hoffman as Penguin (Apart from DeVito he's all I could think of)
Amy Adans as Poison Ivy (red hair close enough)
John Malvonich as Mr Freeze (big guy with a intelligent to him)
Zooey Deschanel as Harley Quinn (she seems a bit off and not there)
Hilary Swank as Talia al Ghoul (not sure why, she seemed to be down to earth which he came off as compared to her dad)
James Gandolfini as Harvey Bullock (like a bull, headstrong and you like and hate him)
Ed Norton as Riddler (not crazy, arrogant)
Eddie Izzard as Calander Man (camp villian like in the long haloween)

[Revenant36]

Not that I'd wanna see all these characters in the same movie, but if there's more than one movie left in this series then I'd like to see

Riddler - David Tennant (http://www.recapist.com/files/images/61774_david-tennant-specs.jpg) or Michael Emerson (http://images.eonline.com/eol_images/Entire_Site/20080425/425.emerson.lost.042508.jpg) (both would be great at somebody driven over the edge by their own genius but I think Tenant would bring a wonderful unhinged quality to the role, without being too zany like Frank Gorshin or Jim Carrey).

Catwoman - Kate Beckinsale (http://www.katebeckinsalegallery.com/images/katebeckinsaleWallpaper/Katebeckinsale-HighQuality/Kate%20in%20Underworld2.jpg) or Natalie Dormer (http://img.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2007/10_04/tudorsDM2310_468x351.jpg). Both are decent enough actresses, highly attractive and have a certain look that just fits Catwoman.

Penguin - Kenneth Cranham (http://dspace.dial.pipex.com/town/parade/abj76/PG/images/national/cottesloe/cardiff_east/kenneth_cranham_97.jpg). I see him more as a gun runner than as a full on mob boss. Deals taking place in the back rooms of the Iceberg Lounge, which he operates as a front for his arms deals. Possibly selling arms to many gangs in order to profit from the gang war that has enveloped Gotham now that they're no longer consolidated under Falcone or Maroni.

Poison Ivy - Someone else already said it but Scarlett Johansson (http://billscontent.blogpeoria.com/files/2007/08/2006-01-13-scarlett_johansson_hq_1.jpg) would be perfect. Ivy could work in the Nolanverse, done as an eco-terrorist who derives toxins from plant extracts, but no "power over plants" stuff. Poison lipstick maybe, at a push.

Black Mask - Kiefer Sutherland. Black Mask's part would mostly be about body language and voice, as he can't work with his facial expressions. In "Phone Booth", Sutherland was pretty much just a vocal part and he just dripped menace. I see Black Mask and his "False Facers" being one of the Gangs that Penguin is supplying.

If I think of any more I'll post them later...

[lukeob94]

Poison Ivy - Someone else already said it but Scarlett Johansson (http://billscontent.blogpeoria.com/files/2007/08/2006-01-13-scarlett_johansson_hq_1.jpg) would be perfect. Ivy could work in the Nolanverse, done as an eco-terrorist who derives toxins from plant extracts, but no "power over plants" stuff. Poison lipstick maybe, at a push.


If I think of any more I'll post them later...


yes!she can be done in batman 3...but i think she can still use toxins to posion people and maybe eeven have aa immunuity to toxins(idk like when they do her background research they find like "woman stuns scinece world having no immunity toi toxins)because alot of plants are toxic and thats very realistic.

but no to scarlet johanseen....yes to christina hendricks

http://i158.photobucket.com/albums/t119/lukeobregon/christina-hendricks2-1.jpg

[flyboy51]

This would be how I'd cast any number of these villains.

Daniel Day-Lewis as Riddler
http://img222.imageshack.us/img222/8515/danieldaylewis.jpg (http://img222.imageshack.us/i/danieldaylewis.jpg/)

Phillip Seymour Hoffman as Penguin
http://img442.imageshack.us/img442/6813/hoffman.jpg (http://img442.imageshack.us/i/hoffman.jpg/)

Jackie Earle Haley as Black Mask
http://img228.imageshack.us/img228/5093/jackieearlehaley01.jpg (http://img228.imageshack.us/i/jackieearlehaley01.jpg/)


Emma Watson as Harley Quinn
http://img228.imageshack.us/img228/5364/emmawatsonc.jpg (http://img228.imageshack.us/i/emmawatsonc.jpg/)


Kate Beckinsale as Catwoman
http://img266.imageshack.us/img266/2668/katebeckinsaleinunderwo.jpg (http://img266.imageshack.us/i/katebeckinsaleinunderwo.jpg/)

Gerard Butler as Hush
http://img137.imageshack.us/img137/7320/gerardbutler.jpg (http://img137.imageshack.us/i/gerardbutler.jpg/)

Javier Bardem as Bane
http://img529.imageshack.us/img529/8933/javierbardem.jpg (http://img529.imageshack.us/i/javierbardem.jpg/)

Jon Voight as Ventriloquist
http://img134.imageshack.us/img134/4318/300voightjon060108.jpg (http://img134.imageshack.us/i/300voightjon060108.jpg/)

Hugh Laurie as Hugo Strange
http://img145.imageshack.us/img145/2615/hughelaurie.jpg (http://img145.imageshack.us/i/hughelaurie.jpg/)

and bring back Scarecrow again, played by Cillian Murphy
http://img230.imageshack.us/img230/6623/cillianmurphy2.jpg (http://img230.imageshack.us/i/cillianmurphy2.jpg/)

As far as a story goes, I think these two scenarios are the most realistic:

1) Harley/Black Mask arc: Joker's doctor at Arkum, Harleen Quinzel, develops a romantic affiliation with her patient and becomes insane and psychopathic herself...even more so than her would-be boyfriend. Following Joker's orders, she begins to torment the city and become the new archnemesis of Batman as well as slowly becoming more unstable throughout the film. Joker unleashing her would be "all part of the plan", however, she's late in the picture because Batman and Gordon are already dealing with the new major crime lord in Gotham known only as the Black Mask, who has taken over Maroni's criminal empire as well as most other criminal elements in the city after Joker left them in dissaray. He has proven himself to be far more ruthless and cruel than the previous mob bosses, and shows no fear of Batman. But he holds a personal hatred of Bruce Wayne, and with his new powerful position in the city he begins to target Wayne Enterprises execs Wayne's friends, including Lucius Fox and Alfred. With two villains disrupting the city, we have the Dark Knight being attacked on two fronts: Harley tries to draw ought the Batman from his cave while Black Mask ensues in his vendetta against Mr. Wayne.

2) Riddler/Penguin/Bane arc: Instead of the emergence of Black Mask as the new crime lord, we have Penguin taking control (albeit in the same manner and with the same brutality as BM in the first arc). He also has some extra muscle: Bane...a large, heavily-muscular and incredibly skilled martial artist that's stronger than Batman and equally as intelligent who works as both muscle and right-hand man for Penguin (Bane is from the Carribbean, where he grew up as a prisoner and learned to fight and read books to become intelligent). While Gordon and Batman are dealing with this, strange riddles, letters, and cyphers are being sent to Gotham's police...theyre not given much notice until brutal, sadistic crimes begin to be committed with a calling card being only a question mark. The media dubs him "the Riddler". The crimes end up being double-pronged, hitting Batman AND Penguins empire...

[flyboy51]

my list(nolan series)

scarecrow:Cillian Murphy
Two Fcae:Arron Eckhart
poison ivy:Christina Hendricks(she is so hot)
Harley:Britanny Murphy
bane:javier bardem
catwoman:omg so many :Racheal Wiez,Catehrin Zeta Jones,or Angelin
(someone please explain to me why angie is not a good choice i mean she is very talented and beautiful?so why she not good catwoman)Charlize theron
r

The only ones i like are Cilian Murphy and Javier Bardem

[royal flush]

http://i175.photobucket.com/albums/w123/paulley55/10846953_profile_mbox_background.jpg

the clock king (like the one in timmeverse)... Played by john lithgow

yes!!!!!