If Harley is in Batman 3, should she have the scars?

[xxhanzyxx]

Let's say Harley IS in Batman 3. Do you think she should have scars similar to that of the Joker?

My opinion is.....

I'm not quite sure :confused:

If they did use the scars, It would be cohesive and a suitably sick demonstration of the obsession/ bonding between the pair (or even the ultimate fangirl turned into a copycat serial killer after Jokers 'disappearance'… but I dunno. (hence where you lot come in?)

[freeze131]

I do not see Harley Quinn working at all in Nolan's Batman.

[mwkcope]

I do not see Harley Quinn working at all in Nolan's Batman.

I concur.Nut is if she was,I agree,she should have da scars.

[Old_BenKenobi]

I think the only way Harley would work is as part of a Joker copycat gang, the same way there were Batman copycats in TDK.

I kinda dig the idea of an angsty "misunderstood" teenaged girl becoming obsessed with "bad boy" Joker and the thought of that obsession making her go a little nuts is interesting and I think it would be a fresh take on the typical Quinn origin that stays true to Nolan's vision.

[DarkVictory]

I don't really want to see Harley without Joker and I think Nolan has made it clear he is not personally interested in recasting Joker, so I'd prefer she weren't in the film.

If, however, she were introduced inot a film with a recast Joker (say, if Nolan moves on from the series and WB decide to continue the universe with a different director), I'd like to see her give herself the scars at the Joker's direction as part of his 'acceptance' of her.

Be a way of showing the type of sick fascination she has for her and the type of control Joker has over her life in a very morbid way.

[Renegade_1975]

I don't really want to see Harley without Joker and I think Nolan has made it clear he is not personally interested in recasting Joker, so I'd prefer she weren't in the film.

If, however, she were introduced inot a film with a recast Joker (say, if Nolan moves on from the series and WB decide to continue the universe with a different director), I'd like to see her give herself the scars at the Joker's direction as part of his 'acceptance' of her.

Be a way of showing the type of sick fascination she has for her and the type of control Joker has over her life in a very morbid way.

I was thinking this when I read the OP's post.

[xxhanzyxx]

I know she won't be in Batman 3, this thread isn't about weather or not you want to see her in this movie and weather it would work or not.

This thread is about IF she were going to be in it, would you think (as a character) having her deface herself in order to be accepted into Jokers gang a good twist or would you rather see her as a hottie like in BAA???

Thanks guys :)

[batmanboy11]

Since she is obssessed with the Joker I would see her scarring herself in order to be more like him. (Providing she and the Joker would be in Batman 3, and they are not :rasp: )

[xxhanzyxx]

(Providing she and the Joker would be in Batman 3, and they are not :rasp: )

Cocky :cool:

[DarkKnightReturns]

I know she won't be in Batman 3, this thread isn't about weather or not you want to see her in this movie and weather it would work or not.

This thread is about IF she were going to be in it, would you think (as a character) having her deface herself in order to be accepted into Jokers gang a good twist or would you rather see her as a hottie like in BAA???

Thanks guys :)

There's just something about Harley that makes her charming in an attractive sort of way even in her sickest incarnations. If she did get the scars, I think she'd become a "butterface".

[Prince Daka]

Na, I don't think she should look freakish as Joker does. Her scars are all mental.

[puppet627]

IMO if they do have Harleen she shouldn't have it until she turns into Harley Quinn. And her outfit should be realy slutty =P

JK.. You'd love it though.

[Prince Daka]

I don't think any smut would be appropriate for Nolan's series. I don't think I've seen any of it in any Nolan movie. He's too classy to use Harley Quinn & Catwoman. Like, has anyone realized we haven't seen a single female villain in his movies?

[batmanboy11]

I don't think any smut would be appropriate for Nolan's series. I don't think I've seen any of it in any Nolan movie. He's too classy to use Harley Quinn & Catwoman. Like, has anyone realized we haven't seen a single female villain in his movies?

To be fair, he's only done two movies and in the other four movies only two had female villians, one in each of those.